Heat Pump or Gas?

Last updated:

By Joshua Kurz

Published:

Where cold-climate heat pumps cost less to run than gas furnaces: 82 of 146 U.S. cities.

Published: November 2026 Prices: winter 2025–26 (Oct–Mar) Coverage: 147 cities, 50 states and DC HVACNATIONALRB-2026-004

Modeled running costs for one reference home at state-average energy prices in a typical-weather winter. These are not anyone’s actual utility bill, and they do not include what a heat pump or furnace costs to buy and install.

82 of 146
cities where a cold-climate heat pump cost less to run than a new gas furnace
71
cities where it was cheaper by more than $50 a winter
72 of 146
cities with a standard heat pump instead (73 gas, 1 even)
+16% vs +10%
median two-winter rise in gas vs heat pump running cost
12 of 12
Texas cities where a heat pump costs least to run

1. Key findings

At last winter’s prices, a cold-climate heat pump cost less to run than a new gas furnace in 82 of the 146 NumeralQ cities with a heating season. It was cheaper by more than $50 a winter in 71 cities. Gas was cheaper by more than $50 in 55, and 20 cities were within $50 either way.

Result (winter 2025–26 prices)RuleCities
Clear heat pump advantageHeat pump costs more than $50 less a winter71
Toss-up, heat pump slightly cheaperHeat pump costs $0 to $50 less11
Toss-up, gas slightly cheaperGas costs $0 to $50 less9
Clear gas advantageGas costs more than $50 less a winter55
Heat pump cheaper overallAny heat pump advantage (71 + 11)82
Gas cheaper overallAny gas advantage (55 + 9)64
  • The country splits roughly in half. Heat pumps win across the South, the Southwest and the Pacific Northwest. Gas wins across the Upper Midwest, the Northeast, Colorado and Alaska. All six California cities are toss-ups. The line follows each state’s electricity price relative to its gas price more than it follows cold weather: Seattle and Spokane favor heat pumps despite long winters because Washington power is cheap.
  • Gas got more expensive faster. From winter 2023–24 to winter 2025–26, the median running cost of heating with gas rose 16%, and with a heat pump 10%. Gas heating costs rose more than 25% in 26 cities, led by Fayetteville, AR (+39%), San Antonio, TX (+35%), Shreveport, LA (+34%), Overland Park, KS (+30%), Tulsa, OK (+29%).
  • 9 cities changed sides in two winters. Heat pumps lost their edge in Washington, DC, Henderson, NV, Las Vegas, NV, Reno, NV, Casper, WY, Cheyenne, WY. They gained it in Overland Park, KS, Wichita, KS, Boston, MA.
  • The biggest savings come from replacing electric resistance heat. Swapping an electric furnace or baseboards for a heat pump saves $353 to $781 a winter in Texas cities and more than $3,000 in Upstate New York, Massachusetts and Maine.

2. Where each system costs less to run

Blue circles mark cities where the heat pump wins by more than $50; orange squares mark cities where gas wins by more than $50; gray rings are the toss-ups. Hover over (or tap) a city for its two costs. The full list is in section 8.

Figure 1. Cheaper to run last winter: cold-climate heat pump or new gas furnace, 146 U.S. citiesMap of 146 cities. A cold-climate heat pump cost more than $50 less to run than a new gas furnace in 71 cities, mostly in the South, Southwest and Pacific Northwest. Gas cost more than $50 less in 55 cities, mostly in the Upper Midwest, Northeast, Colorado and Alaska. 20 cities were within $50 either way, including all six California cities.Which costs less to run: a cold-climate heat pump or a new gas furnace?Modeled winter 2025–26 heating cost for the same reference home, at state-average prices.Heat pump cheaper by more than $50 (71)Gas cheaper by more than $50 (55)Within $50 either way (20)Seattle, WA: gas furnace $795, cold-climate heat pump $515 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $280.Bellevue, WA: gas furnace $795, cold-climate heat pump $515 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $280.Tacoma, WA: gas furnace $867, cold-climate heat pump $564 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $303.Spokane, WA: gas furnace $1,068, cold-climate heat pump $751 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $317.Portland, OR: gas furnace $712, cold-climate heat pump $516 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $196.Missoula, MT: gas furnace $737, cold-climate heat pump $936 a winter; gas cheaper by $199.Salem, OR: gas furnace $753, cold-climate heat pump $551 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $202.Bismarck, ND: gas furnace $828, cold-climate heat pump $1,062 a winter; gas cheaper by $234.Fargo, ND: gas furnace $860, cold-climate heat pump $1,137 a winter; gas cheaper by $277.Eugene, OR: gas furnace $801, cold-climate heat pump $591 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $210.Burlington, VT: gas furnace $1,298, cold-climate heat pump $1,586 a winter; gas cheaper by $288.Billings, MT: gas furnace $663, cold-climate heat pump $833 a winter; gas cheaper by $170.Portland, ME: gas furnace $1,398, cold-climate heat pump $1,872 a winter; gas cheaper by $474.Manchester, NH: gas furnace $1,311, cold-climate heat pump $1,530 a winter; gas cheaper by $219.Boise, ID: gas furnace $428, cold-climate heat pump $586 a winter; gas cheaper by $158.Nashua, NH: gas furnace $1,311, cold-climate heat pump $1,530 a winter; gas cheaper by $219.Minneapolis, MN: gas furnace $880, cold-climate heat pump $1,146 a winter; gas cheaper by $266.St. Paul, MN: gas furnace $885, cold-climate heat pump $1,155 a winter; gas cheaper by $270.Green Bay, WI: gas furnace $957, cold-climate heat pump $1,349 a winter; gas cheaper by $392.Albany, NY: gas furnace $1,221, cold-climate heat pump $1,677 a winter; gas cheaper by $456.Worcester, MA: gas furnace $1,822, cold-climate heat pump $1,893 a winter; gas cheaper by $71.Rochester, NY: gas furnace $1,205, cold-climate heat pump $1,622 a winter; gas cheaper by $417.Rapid City, SD: gas furnace $788, cold-climate heat pump $963 a winter; gas cheaper by $175.Springfield, MA: gas furnace $1,741, cold-climate heat pump $1,840 a winter; gas cheaper by $99.Providence, RI: gas furnace $1,266, cold-climate heat pump $1,496 a winter; gas cheaper by $230.Buffalo, NY: gas furnace $1,242, cold-climate heat pump $1,674 a winter; gas cheaper by $432.Hartford, CT: gas furnace $1,095, cold-climate heat pump $1,442 a winter; gas cheaper by $347.Sioux Falls, SD: gas furnace $787, cold-climate heat pump $989 a winter; gas cheaper by $202.Grand Rapids, MI: gas furnace $777, cold-climate heat pump $1,192 a winter; gas cheaper by $415.Milwaukee, WI: gas furnace $822, cold-climate heat pump $1,094 a winter; gas cheaper by $272.Madison, WI: gas furnace $910, cold-climate heat pump $1,272 a winter; gas cheaper by $362.Casper, WY: gas furnace $924, cold-climate heat pump $981 a winter; gas cheaper by $57.Erie, PA: gas furnace $960, cold-climate heat pump $1,088 a winter; gas cheaper by $128.Detroit, MI: gas furnace $740, cold-climate heat pump $1,123 a winter; gas cheaper by $383.Jersey City, NJ: gas furnace $752, cold-climate heat pump $948 a winter; gas cheaper by $196.Newark, NJ: gas furnace $752, cold-climate heat pump $948 a winter; gas cheaper by $196.New York City, NY: gas furnace $874, cold-climate heat pump $1,104 a winter; gas cheaper by $230.Rockford, IL: gas furnace $775, cold-climate heat pump $1,096 a winter; gas cheaper by $321.Cleveland, OH: gas furnace $768, cold-climate heat pump $871 a winter; gas cheaper by $103.Allentown, PA: gas furnace $860, cold-climate heat pump $974 a winter; gas cheaper by $114.Chicago, IL: gas furnace $686, cold-climate heat pump $932 a winter; gas cheaper by $246.Cedar Rapids, IA: gas furnace $761, cold-climate heat pump $865 a winter; gas cheaper by $104.Trenton, NJ: gas furnace $796, cold-climate heat pump $1,016 a winter; gas cheaper by $220.Aurora, IL: gas furnace $767, cold-climate heat pump $1,083 a winter; gas cheaper by $316.Naperville, IL: gas furnace $759, cold-climate heat pump $1,061 a winter; gas cheaper by $302.Akron, OH: gas furnace $772, cold-climate heat pump $892 a winter; gas cheaper by $120.Reno, NV: gas furnace $522, cold-climate heat pump $586 a winter; gas cheaper by $64.Philadelphia, PA: gas furnace $726, cold-climate heat pump $794 a winter; gas cheaper by $68.Des Moines, IA: gas furnace $689, cold-climate heat pump $764 a winter; gas cheaper by $75.Fort Wayne, IN: gas furnace $726, cold-climate heat pump $912 a winter; gas cheaper by $186.Pittsburgh, PA: gas furnace $879, cold-climate heat pump $988 a winter; gas cheaper by $109.Wilmington, DE: gas furnace $847, cold-climate heat pump $706 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $141.Omaha, NE: gas furnace $733, cold-climate heat pump $680 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $53.Fort Collins, CO: gas furnace $829, cold-climate heat pump $1,103 a winter; gas cheaper by $274.Columbus, OH: gas furnace $729, cold-climate heat pump $836 a winter; gas cheaper by $107.Washington, DC: gas furnace $682, cold-climate heat pump $769 a winter; gas cheaper by $87.Dayton, OH: gas furnace $718, cold-climate heat pump $822 a winter; gas cheaper by $104.Indianapolis, IN: gas furnace $639, cold-climate heat pump $785 a winter; gas cheaper by $146.Denver, CO: gas furnace $698, cold-climate heat pump $895 a winter; gas cheaper by $197.Cincinnati, OH: gas furnace $670, cold-climate heat pump $762 a winter; gas cheaper by $92.Colorado Springs, CO: gas furnace $713, cold-climate heat pump $905 a winter; gas cheaper by $192.Kansas City, MO: gas furnace $744, cold-climate heat pump $511 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $233.Richmond, VA: gas furnace $661, cold-climate heat pump $518 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $143.Overland Park, KS: gas furnace $724, cold-climate heat pump $656 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $68.St. Louis, MO: gas furnace $733, cold-climate heat pump $499 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $234.Louisville, KY: gas furnace $622, cold-climate heat pump $497 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $125.Lexington, KY: gas furnace $664, cold-climate heat pump $537 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $127.Norfolk, VA: gas furnace $549, cold-climate heat pump $414 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $135.Virginia Beach, VA: gas furnace $605, cold-climate heat pump $464 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $141.Chesapeake, VA: gas furnace $497, cold-climate heat pump $379 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $118.Evansville, IN: gas furnace $528, cold-climate heat pump $632 a winter; gas cheaper by $104.Wichita, KS: gas furnace $648, cold-climate heat pump $587 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $61.Durham, NC: gas furnace $611, cold-climate heat pump $388 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $223.Greensboro, NC: gas furnace $679, cold-climate heat pump $433 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $246.Raleigh, NC: gas furnace $611, cold-climate heat pump $388 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $223.Cary, NC: gas furnace $611, cold-climate heat pump $388 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $223.Knoxville, TN: gas furnace $474, cold-climate heat pump $404 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $70.Nashville, TN: gas furnace $452, cold-climate heat pump $385 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $67.Charlotte, NC: gas furnace $593, cold-climate heat pump $376 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $217.Tulsa, OK: gas furnace $537, cold-climate heat pump $394 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $143.Fayetteville, AR: gas furnace $880, cold-climate heat pump $466 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $414.Greenville, SC: gas furnace $474, cold-climate heat pump $347 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $127.Albuquerque, NM: gas furnace $471, cold-climate heat pump $527 a winter; gas cheaper by $56.Chattanooga, TN: gas furnace $407, cold-climate heat pump $342 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $65.Oklahoma City, OK: gas furnace $562, cold-climate heat pump $416 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $146.Memphis, TN: gas furnace $386, cold-climate heat pump $321 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $65.Huntsville, AL: gas furnace $518, cold-climate heat pump $390 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $128.Columbia, SC: gas furnace $396, cold-climate heat pump $288 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $108.Little Rock, AR: gas furnace $682, cold-climate heat pump $348 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $334.Scottsdale, AZ: gas furnace $222, cold-climate heat pump $145 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $77.Phoenix, AZ: gas furnace $234, cold-climate heat pump $152 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $82.Marietta, GA: gas furnace $512, cold-climate heat pump $336 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $176.Mesa, AZ: gas furnace $170, cold-climate heat pump $109 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $61.Gilbert, AZ: gas furnace $170, cold-climate heat pump $109 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $61.Chandler, AZ: gas furnace $170, cold-climate heat pump $109 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $61.Atlanta, GA: gas furnace $512, cold-climate heat pump $336 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $176.Charleston, SC: gas furnace $291, cold-climate heat pump $201 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $90.Birmingham, AL: gas furnace $463, cold-climate heat pump $345 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $118.McKinney, TX: gas furnace $524, cold-climate heat pump $333 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $191.Frisco, TX: gas furnace $524, cold-climate heat pump $333 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $191.Tucson, AZ: gas furnace $260, cold-climate heat pump $173 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $87.Plano, TX: gas furnace $524, cold-climate heat pump $333 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $191.Savannah, GA: gas furnace $309, cold-climate heat pump $197 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $112.Dallas, TX: gas furnace $418, cold-climate heat pump $259 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $159.Fort Worth, TX: gas furnace $425, cold-climate heat pump $266 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $159.Montgomery, AL: gas furnace $366, cold-climate heat pump $274 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $92.Arlington, TX: gas furnace $446, cold-climate heat pump $279 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $167.Shreveport, LA: gas furnace $401, cold-climate heat pump $219 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $182.Jackson, MS: gas furnace $342, cold-climate heat pump $259 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $83.Jacksonville, FL: gas furnace $247, cold-climate heat pump $115 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $132.Mobile, AL: gas furnace $257, cold-climate heat pump $184 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $73.Gulfport, MS: gas furnace $243, cold-climate heat pump $179 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $64.Baton Rouge, LA: gas furnace $298, cold-climate heat pump $159 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $139.Round Rock, TX: gas furnace $303, cold-climate heat pump $185 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $118.Austin, TX: gas furnace $303, cold-climate heat pump $185 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $118.New Orleans, LA: gas furnace $220, cold-climate heat pump $113 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $107.The Woodlands, TX: gas furnace $287, cold-climate heat pump $175 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $112.Houston, TX: gas furnace $231, cold-climate heat pump $137 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $94.Sugar Land, TX: gas furnace $241, cold-climate heat pump $144 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $97.San Antonio, TX: gas furnace $302, cold-climate heat pump $186 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $116.Orlando, FL: gas furnace $137, cold-climate heat pump $63 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $74.Tampa, FL: gas furnace $113, cold-climate heat pump $51 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $62.Clearwater, FL: gas furnace $117, cold-climate heat pump $53 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $64.St. Petersburg, FL: gas furnace $93, cold-climate heat pump $41 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $52.Anchorage, AK: gas furnace $1,486, cold-climate heat pump $2,619 a winter; gas cheaper by $1,133.Sarasota, FL: gas furnace $103, cold-climate heat pump $47 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $56.Boston, MA: gas furnace $1,525, cold-climate heat pump $1,519 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $6.Salt Lake City, UT: gas furnace $608, cold-climate heat pump $604 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $4.Cheyenne, WY: gas furnace $859, cold-climate heat pump $879 a winter; gas cheaper by $20.Provo, UT: gas furnace $608, cold-climate heat pump $604 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $4.Sacramento, CA: gas furnace $529, cold-climate heat pump $555 a winter; gas cheaper by $26.Lincoln, NE: gas furnace $715, cold-climate heat pump $669 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $46.Baltimore, MD: gas furnace $697, cold-climate heat pump $685 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $12.San Francisco, CA: gas furnace $688, cold-climate heat pump $689 a winter; gas cheaper by $1.Rockville, MD: gas furnace $681, cold-climate heat pump $670 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $11.San Jose, CA: gas furnace $541, cold-climate heat pump $565 a winter; gas cheaper by $24.Charleston, WV: gas furnace $627, cold-climate heat pump $580 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $47.Las Vegas, NV: gas furnace $223, cold-climate heat pump $230 a winter; gas cheaper by $7.Henderson, NV: gas furnace $205, cold-climate heat pump $210 a winter; gas cheaper by $5.Los Angeles, CA: gas furnace $344, cold-climate heat pump $346 a winter; gas cheaper by $2.Irvine, CA: gas furnace $270, cold-climate heat pump $271 a winter; gas cheaper by $1.San Diego, CA: gas furnace $327, cold-climate heat pump $335 a winter; gas cheaper by $8.West Palm Beach, FL: gas furnace $53, cold-climate heat pump $23 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $30.Cape Coral, FL: gas furnace $66, cold-climate heat pump $29 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $37.Fort Lauderdale, FL: gas furnace $38, cold-climate heat pump $17 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $21.Miami, FL: gas furnace $36, cold-climate heat pump $16 a winter; heat pump cheaper by $20.Sources: EIA residential electricity and natural gas prices by state, Oct 2025–Mar 2026; NOAA 1991–2020 climate normals;NumeralQ heating cost model (RB-2026-004). Honolulu, which has no heating season, is not shown.
Figure 1. Which system cost less to run last winter in each city: a cold-climate heat pump or a new 95% efficient gas furnace, for the same reference home. Sources: EIA residential electricity (Form 861M) and natural gas prices by state, October 2025 to March 2026; NOAA 1991–2020 U.S. Climate Normals; NumeralQ heating cost model. Download SVG
Show the numbers behind this chart
CityResultGas furnaceCold-climate heat pump
Anchorage, AKClear gas advantage$1,486$2,619
Birmingham, ALClear heat pump advantage$463$345
Huntsville, ALClear heat pump advantage$518$390
Mobile, ALClear heat pump advantage$257$184
Montgomery, ALClear heat pump advantage$366$274
Fayetteville, ARClear heat pump advantage$880$466
Little Rock, ARClear heat pump advantage$682$348
Chandler, AZClear heat pump advantage$170$109
Gilbert, AZClear heat pump advantage$170$109
Mesa, AZClear heat pump advantage$170$109
Phoenix, AZClear heat pump advantage$234$152
Scottsdale, AZClear heat pump advantage$222$145
Tucson, AZClear heat pump advantage$260$173
Irvine, CAToss-up, gas slightly cheaper$270$271
Los Angeles, CAToss-up, gas slightly cheaper$344$346
Sacramento, CAToss-up, gas slightly cheaper$529$555
San Diego, CAToss-up, gas slightly cheaper$327$335
San Francisco, CAToss-up, gas slightly cheaper$688$689
San Jose, CAToss-up, gas slightly cheaper$541$565
Colorado Springs, COClear gas advantage$713$905
Denver, COClear gas advantage$698$895
Fort Collins, COClear gas advantage$829$1,103
Hartford, CTClear gas advantage$1,095$1,442
Washington, DCClear gas advantage$682$769
Wilmington, DEClear heat pump advantage$847$706
Cape Coral, FLToss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper$66$29
Clearwater, FLClear heat pump advantage$117$53
Fort Lauderdale, FLToss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper$38$17
Jacksonville, FLClear heat pump advantage$247$115
Miami, FLToss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper$36$16
Orlando, FLClear heat pump advantage$137$63
Sarasota, FLClear heat pump advantage$103$47
St. Petersburg, FLClear heat pump advantage$93$41
Tampa, FLClear heat pump advantage$113$51
West Palm Beach, FLToss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper$53$23
Atlanta, GAClear heat pump advantage$512$336
Marietta, GAClear heat pump advantage$512$336
Savannah, GAClear heat pump advantage$309$197
Cedar Rapids, IAClear gas advantage$761$865
Des Moines, IAClear gas advantage$689$764
Boise, IDClear gas advantage$428$586
Aurora, ILClear gas advantage$767$1,083
Chicago, ILClear gas advantage$686$932
Naperville, ILClear gas advantage$759$1,061
Rockford, ILClear gas advantage$775$1,096
Evansville, INClear gas advantage$528$632
Fort Wayne, INClear gas advantage$726$912
Indianapolis, INClear gas advantage$639$785
Overland Park, KSClear heat pump advantage$724$656
Wichita, KSClear heat pump advantage$648$587
Lexington, KYClear heat pump advantage$664$537
Louisville, KYClear heat pump advantage$622$497
Baton Rouge, LAClear heat pump advantage$298$159
New Orleans, LAClear heat pump advantage$220$113
Shreveport, LAClear heat pump advantage$401$219
Boston, MAToss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper$1,525$1,519
Springfield, MAClear gas advantage$1,741$1,840
Worcester, MAClear gas advantage$1,822$1,893
Baltimore, MDToss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper$697$685
Rockville, MDToss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper$681$670
Portland, MEClear gas advantage$1,398$1,872
Detroit, MIClear gas advantage$740$1,123
Grand Rapids, MIClear gas advantage$777$1,192
Minneapolis, MNClear gas advantage$880$1,146
St. Paul, MNClear gas advantage$885$1,155
Kansas City, MOClear heat pump advantage$744$511
St. Louis, MOClear heat pump advantage$733$499
Gulfport, MSClear heat pump advantage$243$179
Jackson, MSClear heat pump advantage$342$259
Billings, MTClear gas advantage$663$833
Missoula, MTClear gas advantage$737$936
Cary, NCClear heat pump advantage$611$388
Charlotte, NCClear heat pump advantage$593$376
Durham, NCClear heat pump advantage$611$388
Greensboro, NCClear heat pump advantage$679$433
Raleigh, NCClear heat pump advantage$611$388
Bismarck, NDClear gas advantage$828$1,062
Fargo, NDClear gas advantage$860$1,137
Lincoln, NEToss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper$715$669
Omaha, NEClear heat pump advantage$733$680
Manchester, NHClear gas advantage$1,311$1,530
Nashua, NHClear gas advantage$1,311$1,530
Jersey City, NJClear gas advantage$752$948
Newark, NJClear gas advantage$752$948
Trenton, NJClear gas advantage$796$1,016
Albuquerque, NMClear gas advantage$471$527
Henderson, NVToss-up, gas slightly cheaper$205$210
Las Vegas, NVToss-up, gas slightly cheaper$223$230
Reno, NVClear gas advantage$522$586
Albany, NYClear gas advantage$1,221$1,677
Buffalo, NYClear gas advantage$1,242$1,674
New York City, NYClear gas advantage$874$1,104
Rochester, NYClear gas advantage$1,205$1,622
Akron, OHClear gas advantage$772$892
Cincinnati, OHClear gas advantage$670$762
Cleveland, OHClear gas advantage$768$871
Columbus, OHClear gas advantage$729$836
Dayton, OHClear gas advantage$718$822
Oklahoma City, OKClear heat pump advantage$562$416
Tulsa, OKClear heat pump advantage$537$394
Eugene, ORClear heat pump advantage$801$591
Portland, ORClear heat pump advantage$712$516
Salem, ORClear heat pump advantage$753$551
Allentown, PAClear gas advantage$860$974
Erie, PAClear gas advantage$960$1,088
Philadelphia, PAClear gas advantage$726$794
Pittsburgh, PAClear gas advantage$879$988
Providence, RIClear gas advantage$1,266$1,496
Charleston, SCClear heat pump advantage$291$201
Columbia, SCClear heat pump advantage$396$288
Greenville, SCClear heat pump advantage$474$347
Rapid City, SDClear gas advantage$788$963
Sioux Falls, SDClear gas advantage$787$989
Chattanooga, TNClear heat pump advantage$407$342
Knoxville, TNClear heat pump advantage$474$404
Memphis, TNClear heat pump advantage$386$321
Nashville, TNClear heat pump advantage$452$385
Arlington, TXClear heat pump advantage$446$279
Austin, TXClear heat pump advantage$303$185
Dallas, TXClear heat pump advantage$418$259
Fort Worth, TXClear heat pump advantage$425$266
Frisco, TXClear heat pump advantage$524$333
Houston, TXClear heat pump advantage$231$137
McKinney, TXClear heat pump advantage$524$333
Plano, TXClear heat pump advantage$524$333
Round Rock, TXClear heat pump advantage$303$185
San Antonio, TXClear heat pump advantage$302$186
Sugar Land, TXClear heat pump advantage$241$144
The Woodlands, TXClear heat pump advantage$287$175
Provo, UTToss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper$608$604
Salt Lake City, UTToss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper$608$604
Chesapeake, VAClear heat pump advantage$497$379
Norfolk, VAClear heat pump advantage$549$414
Richmond, VAClear heat pump advantage$661$518
Virginia Beach, VAClear heat pump advantage$605$464
Burlington, VTClear gas advantage$1,298$1,586
Bellevue, WAClear heat pump advantage$795$515
Seattle, WAClear heat pump advantage$795$515
Spokane, WAClear heat pump advantage$1,068$751
Tacoma, WAClear heat pump advantage$867$564
Green Bay, WIClear gas advantage$957$1,349
Madison, WIClear gas advantage$910$1,272
Milwaukee, WIClear gas advantage$822$1,094
Charleston, WVToss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper$627$580
Casper, WYClear gas advantage$924$981
Cheyenne, WYToss-up, gas slightly cheaper$859$879

3. Equipment choice changes the answer in 10 cities

With a standard heat pump in place of a cold-climate model, the count falls from 82 to 72 cities, and the country splits almost exactly in half: 72 cities favor the heat pump, 73 favor gas, and in Charleston, WV the two cost the same to the dollar.

The primary comparison uses the lower-cost operating option between a standard and a cold-climate heat pump. In this model, the cold-climate system was more efficient in every city, so it determined the headline results. We also report the standard heat pump comparison separately to show how equipment selection affects the results.

Figure 2. How the choice of heat pump changes the countTwo stacked bars of 146 cities. With a cold-climate heat pump: 71 clear heat pump, 20 within $50, 55 clear gas; heat pump cheaper overall in 82. With a standard heat pump: 63 clear heat pump, 20 within $50, 63 clear gas; heat pump cheaper overall in 72.Cities where each system costs less to run, by type of heat pumpHeat pump cheaper by more than $50Within $50 either wayGas cheaper by more than $50Cold-climate heat pumpHeat pump cheaper overall: 82Cold-climate heat pump: 71 cities heat pump cheaper by more than $5071Cold-climate heat pump: 20 cities within $50 either way20Cold-climate heat pump: 55 cities gas cheaper by more than $5055Standard heat pumpHeat pump cheaper overall: 72Standard heat pump: 63 cities heat pump cheaper by more than $5063Standard heat pump: 20 cities within $50 either way20Standard heat pump: 63 cities gas cheaper by more than $5063146 cities with a heating season. EIA state prices, Oct 2025–Mar 2026; NOAA 1991–2020 normals; NumeralQ model.
Figure 2. Number of the 146 cities where each system costs less to run, with a cold-climate heat pump and with a standard heat pump. Source: NumeralQ heating cost model using EIA and NOAA data. Download SVG
Show the numbers behind this chart
ScenarioClear heat pump (> $50)Toss-up, heat pump cheaperEqual costToss-up, gas cheaperClear gas (> $50)Heat pump cheaper overallGas cheaper overall
Cold-climate heat pump (headline)711109558264
Standard heat pump639110637273

4. Where the gap is largest

The heat pump’s biggest advantage is in Arkansas and Washington; gas’s biggest is in Alaska, Maine, Upstate New York and the Great Lakes.

Figure 3. The 10 cities where a heat pump saves the most and the 10 where gas saves the mostDiverging bars of the yearly running-cost gap. Heat pump savings lead in Fayetteville, AR ($414). Gas savings lead in Anchorage, AK ($1,133).Yearly running-cost gap, winter 2025–26 pricesHeat pump saves this muchGas furnace saves this much$400$0$400$800$1,200Fayetteville, AR: gas furnace $880, cold-climate heat pump $466; heat pump saves $414 a winter.Fayetteville, AR$414Little Rock, AR: gas furnace $682, cold-climate heat pump $348; heat pump saves $334 a winter.Little Rock, AR$334Spokane, WA: gas furnace $1,068, cold-climate heat pump $751; heat pump saves $317 a winter.Spokane, WA$317Tacoma, WA: gas furnace $867, cold-climate heat pump $564; heat pump saves $303 a winter.Tacoma, WA$303Bellevue, WA: gas furnace $795, cold-climate heat pump $515; heat pump saves $280 a winter.Bellevue, WA$280Seattle, WA: gas furnace $795, cold-climate heat pump $515; heat pump saves $280 a winter.Seattle, WA$280Greensboro, NC: gas furnace $679, cold-climate heat pump $433; heat pump saves $246 a winter.Greensboro, NC$246St. Louis, MO: gas furnace $733, cold-climate heat pump $499; heat pump saves $234 a winter.St. Louis, MO$234Kansas City, MO: gas furnace $744, cold-climate heat pump $511; heat pump saves $233 a winter.Kansas City, MO$233Cary, NC: gas furnace $611, cold-climate heat pump $388; heat pump saves $223 a winter.Cary, NC$223Hartford, CT: gas furnace $1,095, cold-climate heat pump $1,442; gas saves $347 a winter.Hartford, CT$347Madison, WI: gas furnace $910, cold-climate heat pump $1,272; gas saves $362 a winter.Madison, WI$362Detroit, MI: gas furnace $740, cold-climate heat pump $1,123; gas saves $383 a winter.Detroit, MI$383Green Bay, WI: gas furnace $957, cold-climate heat pump $1,349; gas saves $392 a winter.Green Bay, WI$392Grand Rapids, MI: gas furnace $777, cold-climate heat pump $1,192; gas saves $415 a winter.Grand Rapids, MI$415Rochester, NY: gas furnace $1,205, cold-climate heat pump $1,622; gas saves $417 a winter.Rochester, NY$417Buffalo, NY: gas furnace $1,242, cold-climate heat pump $1,674; gas saves $432 a winter.Buffalo, NY$432Albany, NY: gas furnace $1,221, cold-climate heat pump $1,677; gas saves $456 a winter.Albany, NY$456Portland, ME: gas furnace $1,398, cold-climate heat pump $1,872; gas saves $474 a winter.Portland, ME$474Anchorage, AK: gas furnace $1,486, cold-climate heat pump $2,619; gas saves $1,133 a winter.Anchorage, AK$1,133Cold-climate heat pump vs new 95% gas furnace, one reference home. EIA state prices; NOAA normals; NumeralQ model.
Figure 3. The 10 cities where a cold-climate heat pump saves the most against a new gas furnace, and the 10 where gas saves the most, in dollars a winter. Source: NumeralQ heating cost model using EIA and NOAA data. Download SVG
Show the numbers behind this chart
CityGas furnaceCold-climate heat pumpGap
Fayetteville, AR$880$466Heat pump saves $414
Little Rock, AR$682$348Heat pump saves $334
Spokane, WA$1,068$751Heat pump saves $317
Tacoma, WA$867$564Heat pump saves $303
Bellevue, WA$795$515Heat pump saves $280
Seattle, WA$795$515Heat pump saves $280
Greensboro, NC$679$433Heat pump saves $246
St. Louis, MO$733$499Heat pump saves $234
Kansas City, MO$744$511Heat pump saves $233
Cary, NC$611$388Heat pump saves $223
Hartford, CT$1,095$1,442Gas saves $347
Madison, WI$910$1,272Gas saves $362
Detroit, MI$740$1,123Gas saves $383
Green Bay, WI$957$1,349Gas saves $392
Grand Rapids, MI$777$1,192Gas saves $415
Rochester, NY$1,205$1,622Gas saves $417
Buffalo, NY$1,242$1,674Gas saves $432
Albany, NY$1,221$1,677Gas saves $456
Portland, ME$1,398$1,872Gas saves $474
Anchorage, AK$1,486$2,619Gas saves $1,133
Heat pump saves mostGas furnaceHeat pumpHeat pump saves
Fayetteville, AR$880$466$414
Little Rock, AR$682$348$334
Spokane, WA$1,068$751$317
Tacoma, WA$867$564$303
Bellevue, WA$795$515$280
Seattle, WA$795$515$280
Greensboro, NC$679$433$246
St. Louis, MO$733$499$234
Kansas City, MO$744$511$233
Cary, NC$611$388$223
Gas saves mostGas furnaceHeat pumpGas saves
Anchorage, AK$1,486$2,619$1,133
Portland, ME$1,398$1,872$474
Albany, NY$1,221$1,677$456
Buffalo, NY$1,242$1,674$432
Rochester, NY$1,205$1,622$417
Grand Rapids, MI$777$1,192$415
Green Bay, WI$957$1,349$392
Detroit, MI$740$1,123$383
Madison, WI$910$1,272$362
Hartford, CT$1,095$1,442$347

Toss-ups (under $50 either way). Heat pump slightly cheaper: Charleston, WV, Lincoln, NE, Cape Coral, FL, West Palm Beach, FL, Fort Lauderdale, FL, Miami, FL, Baltimore, MD, Rockville, MD, Boston, MA, Provo, UT, Salt Lake City, UT. Gas slightly cheaper: Irvine, CA, San Francisco, CA, Los Angeles, CA, Henderson, NV, Las Vegas, NV, San Diego, CA, Cheyenne, WY, San Jose, CA, Sacramento, CA. In these cities the answer depends on the home and the utility’s rate, not on the region.


5. Texas: heat pumps win in all 12 cities

A heat pump was the cheapest way to heat in all 12 Texas cities in the study, with either type of heat pump. Texas residential gas cost 38% more per unit last winter than in winter 2023–24 ($14.62 to $20.12 per thousand cubic feet), while electricity rose 8% (14.7 to 15.9 cents per kWh). These are statewide prices applied to each city’s own climate, not utility-by-utility rates.

About three in ten Texas homes heat mainly with electric resistance. In EIA’s 2020 Residential Energy Consumption Survey household file (1,016 Texas homes, weighted), 51.4% of Texas homes heat mainly with electricity. Of all Texas homes, 20.3% use an electric central furnace, 4.9% built-in electric heaters (baseboard, wall or ceiling) and 5.7% portable electric heaters as their main heat: 31.0% in all. Only 19.8% use a heat pump (central or ductless). The survey is from 2020 and self-reported, so treat 31% as an estimate.

Figure 4. Texas: yearly heating cost by system, 12 citiesDot plot for 12 Texas cities. In every city a heat pump costs least, a gas furnace is in the middle and electric resistance costs most. Plano, Frisco and McKinney: heat pump $333, gas $524, resistance $1,114.Texas: what it costs to heat the reference home, winter 2025–26 pricesCold-climate heat pumpGas furnace (95%)Electric resistance$0$300$600$900$1,200Frisco, TX: heat pump $333, gas furnace $524, electric resistance $1,114 a winter.Frisco$1,114McKinney, TX: heat pump $333, gas furnace $524, electric resistance $1,114 a winter.McKinney$1,114Plano, TX: heat pump $333, gas furnace $524, electric resistance $1,114 a winter.Plano$1,114Arlington, TX: heat pump $279, gas furnace $446, electric resistance $949 a winter.Arlington$949Fort Worth, TX: heat pump $266, gas furnace $425, electric resistance $904 a winter.Fort Worth$904Dallas, TX: heat pump $259, gas furnace $418, electric resistance $889 a winter.Dallas$889Austin, TX: heat pump $185, gas furnace $303, electric resistance $644 a winter.Austin$644Round Rock, TX: heat pump $185, gas furnace $303, electric resistance $644 a winter.Round Rock$644San Antonio, TX: heat pump $186, gas furnace $302, electric resistance $642 a winter.San Antonio$642The Woodlands, TX: heat pump $175, gas furnace $287, electric resistance $611 a winter.The Woodlands$611Sugar Land, TX: heat pump $144, gas furnace $241, electric resistance $512 a winter.Sugar Land$512Houston, TX: heat pump $137, gas furnace $231, electric resistance $490 a winter.Houston$490Texas statewide EIA prices, Oct 2025–Mar 2026, with each city's NOAA 1991–2020 climate normals; NumeralQ model.
Figure 4. Yearly cost to heat the reference home in 12 Texas cities with a cold-climate heat pump, a new gas furnace and electric resistance. Sources: EIA Texas residential prices, October 2025 to March 2026; NOAA 1991–2020 normals; NumeralQ heating cost model. Download SVG
CityGas furnaceCold-climate heat pumpStandard heat pumpElectric resistanceResistance to heat pump saves
Frisco$524$333$357$1,114$781
McKinney$524$333$357$1,114$781
Plano$524$333$357$1,114$781
Arlington$446$279$299$949$670
Fort Worth$425$266$285$904$638
Dallas$418$259$277$889$630
Austin$303$185$197$644$459
Round Rock$303$185$197$644$459
San Antonio$302$186$198$642$456
The Woodlands$287$175$186$611$436
Sugar Land$241$144$153$512$368
Houston$231$137$145$490$353

Cities that share a NOAA weather station and the statewide price show the same figures (Plano, Frisco and McKinney; Austin and Round Rock).


6. This winter: EIA’s outlook

This section is context, not a result of our model. EIA’s 2026–27 Winter Fuels Outlook, released 6 October 2026, expects households that heat mainly with natural gas or propane to spend less than last winter, and households that heat with electricity or heating oil to spend more. That is a national spending forecast that includes expected weather. It does not decide which system costs less in any one city or home, and the results on this page are not adjusted for it.


7. Methodology and limitations

How we modeled each heating system
  • One reference home everywhere. Heat loss of 400 Btu per hour per °F, about a 2,000 sq ft home built to 1990s code. Every system heats the same home, so the winner in a city does not depend on home size; only the dollar amounts do.
  • Heat needed, month by month. Heat needed = 400 × 24 × the month’s normal heating degree days (base 65 °F), from NOAA’s 1991–2020 monthly U.S. Climate Normals. The year is the sum of the months.
  • Weather station. The nearest NOAA first-order station with complete monthly normals. Median distance 9 km; the farthest are Provo (Salt Lake City airport, 65 km), Fort Collins (Nunn, 39 km) and Anchorage (Merrill Field, 31 km). Each city’s station and distance are in the data file.
  • Gas furnace. The headline compares a new 95% efficient furnace. An 80% furnace (an older unit) is a separate column for the “replace an old furnace” case. Both add 9 kWh of blower electricity per million Btu of heat. Gas is converted at 1.036 million Btu per thousand cubic feet.
  • Electric resistance. 100% efficient: 3,412 Btu of heat per kWh.
  • Heat pump efficiency (coefficient of performance, COP) at a given outdoor temperature. Straight-line interpolation between assumed points. Standard heat pump: 2.3 at 17 °F, rising 1.0 for every 30 °F warmer, capped at 3.6, never below 1.0. Cold-climate heat pump: 2.0 at 5 °F, 2.6 at 17 °F, 3.5 at 47 °F, capped at 3.8, floor 1.5, with resistance only below −13 °F. These are typical values we assumed, not the rating of one product. The cold-climate value at 5 °F is above the NEEP cold-climate specification minimum of 1.75.
  • Backup heat (standard heat pump only). Electric backup takes a share of the load that grows in a straight line from 0% at 25 °F to 100% at −5 °F.
  • From temperatures to a winter figure. Each month’s efficiency is figured at its normal daily low and normal daily high, weighted by how far each is below 65 °F, and the months are combined by their heating degree days. Both heat pumps are computed for every city and the headline uses whichever costs less to run; the data file names the model used.
  • Prices. EIA state residential electricity price for October to March, weighted by sales (total revenue divided by total kWh, Form 861M). EIA state residential natural gas price for the same months, weighted by monthly residential volume. “Last winter” is October 2025 to March 2026; the comparison is October 2023 to March 2024.
  • No NumeralQ cost estimates are used. No install prices, rebates or tax credits.

Limitations

  • These are modeled costs at state-average prices, not actual local utility bills. Cities in the same state differ only by climate, and a home on a time-of-use or tiered rate can see different results.
  • Average prices include fixed monthly charges, which don’t rise with heating use. Counting them as part of each kWh or cubic foot overstates the extra cost of heating with either fuel.
  • Normals describe a typical winter. These are not predictions for winter 2026–27.
  • Heat pump efficiency is the largest assumption. Lowering both heat pumps’ efficiency by 10% in every city cuts the cities where a heat pump wins from 82 to 72; raising it by 10% lifts the count to 95.
  • Running cost only. A heat pump can cost more or less to install than a furnace, and that can outweigh a small running-cost difference.
  • Honolulu has no heating season and is left out of the counts. It stays in the data file.

8. Look up a city

Modeled winter heating cost for the reference home in all 147 cities, at winter 2025–26 prices. The “Result” column compares the cold-climate heat pump with the 95% gas furnace.

All 147 cities
CityHeating degree daysGas furnace (95%)Cold-climate heat pumpStandard heat pumpElectric resistanceResult
Anchorage, AK9,902$1,486$2,619$3,513$7,252Gas
Birmingham, AL2,534$463$345$369$1,163Heat pump
Huntsville, AL2,831$518$390$418$1,299Heat pump
Mobile, AL1,404$257$184$196$644Heat pump
Montgomery, AL2,000$366$274$293$918Heat pump
Fayetteville, AR4,080$880$466$504$1,476Heat pump
Little Rock, AR3,164$682$348$374$1,145Heat pump
Chandler, AZ874$170$109$116$385Heat pump
Gilbert, AZ874$170$109$116$385Heat pump
Mesa, AZ874$170$109$116$385Heat pump
Phoenix, AZ1,202$234$152$162$529Heat pump
Scottsdale, AZ1,139$222$145$154$501Heat pump
Tucson, AZ1,332$260$173$185$586Heat pump
Irvine, CA1,092$270$271$286$981Toss-up (gas)
Los Angeles, CA1,388$344$346$365$1,247Toss-up (gas)
Sacramento, CA2,138$529$555$590$1,922Toss-up (gas)
San Diego, CA1,320$327$335$355$1,187Toss-up (gas)
San Francisco, CA2,781$688$689$728$2,499Toss-up (gas)
San Jose, CA2,184$541$565$601$1,962Toss-up (gas)
Colorado Springs, CO5,889$713$905$1,101$2,711Gas
Denver, CO5,765$698$895$1,111$2,654Gas
Fort Collins, CO6,845$829$1,103$1,456$3,151Gas
Hartford, CT5,620$1,095$1,442$1,648$4,460Gas
Washington, DC3,769$682$769$827$2,537Gas
Wilmington, DE4,647$847$706$763$2,257Heat pump
Cape Coral, FL252$66$29$31$111Toss-up (heat pump)
Clearwater, FL446$117$53$55$196Heat pump
Fort Lauderdale, FL146$38$17$18$64Toss-up (heat pump)
Jacksonville, FL944$247$115$121$415Heat pump
Miami, FL138$36$16$17$61Toss-up (heat pump)
Orlando, FL525$137$63$66$231Heat pump
Sarasota, FL394$103$47$49$173Heat pump
St. Petersburg, FL357$93$41$44$157Heat pump
Tampa, FL433$113$51$54$190Heat pump
West Palm Beach, FL202$53$23$25$89Toss-up (heat pump)
Atlanta, GA2,775$512$336$361$1,119Heat pump
Marietta, GA2,775$512$336$361$1,119Heat pump
Savannah, GA1,675$309$197$209$675Heat pump
Honolulu, HI0$0$0$0$0No heating season
Cedar Rapids, IA6,824$761$865$1,107$2,492Gas
Des Moines, IA6,178$689$764$956$2,256Gas
Boise, ID5,321$428$586$635$1,849Gas
Aurora, IL6,433$767$1,083$1,335$3,209Gas
Chicago, IL5,753$686$932$1,068$2,870Gas
Naperville, IL6,364$759$1,061$1,286$3,174Gas
Rockford, IL6,497$775$1,096$1,354$3,241Gas
Evansville, IN4,340$528$632$683$2,018Gas
Fort Wayne, IN5,968$726$912$1,066$2,776Gas
Indianapolis, IN5,250$639$785$884$2,442Gas
Overland Park, KS4,926$724$656$735$2,050Heat pump
Wichita, KS4,414$648$587$651$1,837Heat pump
Lexington, KY4,432$664$537$580$1,717Heat pump
Louisville, KY4,150$622$497$536$1,608Heat pump
Baton Rouge, LA1,534$298$159$169$552Heat pump
New Orleans, LA1,134$220$113$119$408Heat pump
Shreveport, LA2,068$401$219$234$745Heat pump
Boston, MA5,546$1,525$1,519$1,672$4,807Toss-up (heat pump)
Springfield, MA6,330$1,741$1,840$2,251$5,487Gas
Worcester, MA6,622$1,822$1,893$2,250$5,741Gas
Baltimore, MD3,858$697$685$736$2,261Toss-up (heat pump)
Rockville, MD3,769$681$670$720$2,209Toss-up (heat pump)
Portland, ME6,795$1,398$1,872$2,268$5,629Gas
Detroit, MI6,106$740$1,123$1,293$3,446Gas
Grand Rapids, MI6,408$777$1,192$1,394$3,617Gas
Minneapolis, MN7,399$880$1,146$1,496$3,212Gas
St. Paul, MN7,443$885$1,155$1,508$3,231Gas
Kansas City, MO4,613$744$511$567$1,607Heat pump
St. Louis, MO4,547$733$499$544$1,584Heat pump
Gulfport, MS1,507$243$179$190$627Heat pump
Jackson, MS2,123$342$259$277$883Heat pump
Billings, MT6,754$663$833$1,003$2,508Gas
Missoula, MT7,514$737$936$1,121$2,791Gas
Cary, NC3,153$611$388$417$1,280Heat pump
Charlotte, NC3,058$593$376$404$1,242Heat pump
Durham, NC3,153$611$388$417$1,280Heat pump
Greensboro, NC3,500$679$433$466$1,421Heat pump
Raleigh, NC3,153$611$388$417$1,280Heat pump
Bismarck, ND8,471$828$1,062$1,473$2,760Gas
Fargo, ND8,806$860$1,137$1,604$2,869Gas
Lincoln, NE5,856$715$669$845$1,971Toss-up (heat pump)
Omaha, NE6,001$733$680$841$2,019Heat pump
Manchester, NH6,172$1,311$1,530$1,827$4,636Gas
Nashua, NH6,172$1,311$1,530$1,827$4,636Gas
Jersey City, NJ4,700$752$948$1,025$3,041Gas
Newark, NJ4,700$752$948$1,025$3,041Gas
Trenton, NJ4,976$796$1,016$1,105$3,219Gas
Albuquerque, NM3,996$471$527$571$1,668Gas
Henderson, NV1,836$205$210$223$725Toss-up (gas)
Las Vegas, NV1,992$223$230$245$786Toss-up (gas)
Reno, NV4,669$522$586$635$1,843Gas
Albany, NY6,357$1,221$1,677$2,036$5,021Gas
Buffalo, NY6,466$1,242$1,674$1,947$5,107Gas
New York City, NY4,553$874$1,104$1,188$3,596Gas
Rochester, NY6,273$1,205$1,622$1,888$4,954Gas
Akron, OH5,538$772$892$1,013$2,763Gas
Cincinnati, OH4,804$670$762$835$2,396Gas
Cleveland, OH5,512$768$871$957$2,750Gas
Columbus, OH5,233$729$836$933$2,611Gas
Dayton, OH5,149$718$822$917$2,569Gas
Oklahoma City, OK3,615$562$416$450$1,338Heat pump
Tulsa, OK3,451$537$394$425$1,277Heat pump
Eugene, OR4,616$801$591$633$1,962Heat pump
Portland, OR4,104$712$516$551$1,745Heat pump
Salem, OR4,341$753$551$589$1,845Heat pump
Allentown, PA5,293$860$974$1,096$3,027Gas
Erie, PA5,905$960$1,088$1,237$3,378Gas
Philadelphia, PA4,466$726$794$858$2,555Gas
Pittsburgh, PA5,407$879$988$1,097$3,093Gas
Providence, RI5,478$1,266$1,496$1,673$4,687Gas
Charleston, SC1,623$291$201$213$717Heat pump
Columbia, SC2,210$396$288$308$976Heat pump
Greenville, SC2,646$474$347$371$1,169Heat pump
Rapid City, SD7,252$788$963$1,265$2,752Gas
Sioux Falls, SD7,248$787$989$1,303$2,751Gas
Chattanooga, TN3,029$407$342$367$1,135Heat pump
Knoxville, TN3,528$474$404$434$1,322Heat pump
Memphis, TN2,875$386$321$344$1,077Heat pump
Nashville, TN3,364$452$385$414$1,261Heat pump
Arlington, TX2,126$446$279$299$949Heat pump
Austin, TX1,442$303$185$197$644Heat pump
Dallas, TX1,992$418$259$277$889Heat pump
Fort Worth, TX2,026$425$266$285$904Heat pump
Frisco, TX2,497$524$333$357$1,114Heat pump
Houston, TX1,098$231$137$145$490Heat pump
McKinney, TX2,497$524$333$357$1,114Heat pump
Plano, TX2,497$524$333$357$1,114Heat pump
Round Rock, TX1,442$303$185$197$644Heat pump
San Antonio, TX1,438$302$186$198$642Heat pump
Sugar Land, TX1,148$241$144$153$512Heat pump
The Woodlands, TX1,368$287$175$186$611Heat pump
Provo, UT5,154$608$604$659$1,907Toss-up (heat pump)
Salt Lake City, UT5,154$608$604$659$1,907Toss-up (heat pump)
Chesapeake, VA2,810$497$379$406$1,264Heat pump
Norfolk, VA3,106$549$414$443$1,398Heat pump
Richmond, VA3,736$661$518$558$1,681Heat pump
Virginia Beach, VA3,423$605$464$498$1,540Heat pump
Burlington, VT6,960$1,298$1,586$1,989$4,633Gas
Bellevue, WA4,483$795$515$550$1,754Heat pump
Seattle, WA4,483$795$515$550$1,754Heat pump
Spokane, WA6,019$1,068$751$815$2,356Heat pump
Tacoma, WA4,884$867$564$603$1,911Heat pump
Green Bay, WI7,505$957$1,349$1,718$3,866Gas
Madison, WI7,138$910$1,272$1,609$3,677Gas
Milwaukee, WI6,450$822$1,094$1,298$3,323Gas
Charleston, WV4,353$627$580$627$1,856Toss-up (heat pump)
Casper, WY7,485$924$981$1,260$2,826Gas
Cheyenne, WY6,959$859$879$1,067$2,628Toss-up (gas)

See your city’s installed price for a heat pump or a furnace.


9. Download the data and sources

Every number and chart on this page is computed from city-heating-costs.csv. The files are the frozen 17 November 2026 version; SHA256SUMS.txt lets you confirm a file is unchanged. The data is free to reuse under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license with credit to NumeralQ.

Sources


10. About this research

RB-2026-004 was prepared by Joshua Kurz, founder of NumeralQ, using public government data. NumeralQ is an independent home-improvement cost research site; see About NumeralQ and our methodology. This study does not use NumeralQ’s cost estimates and received no outside funding. For questions or data requests, contact us.

How to cite

Kurz, J. (2026). Heat Pump or Gas? Where Cold-Climate Heat Pumps Cost Less to Run in 82 of 146 U.S. Cities (Research Brief RB-2026-004). NumeralQ. https://www.numeralq.com/research/heat-pump-vs-gas-heating-costs