Storm Chaser States

By Joshua Kurz

Last updated:

Where U.S. hail falls, and what each state requires of the roofers who follow it.

Published: November 2026 Research cutoff: 6 November 2026 Coverage: 50 states and DC ROOFINGNATIONALRB-2026-003

Research cutoff: 6 November 2026. Laws are stated as in force on that date. Some classifications are scheduled for a recheck around 1 February 2027 (section 8).

42.6%
of NOAA large-hail reports, 2015–2024, came from the 15 states with no state roofing credential
60.5%
of FEMA modeled annual hail loss ($2.52B nationally) falls in those 15 states
23
states ban roofers from waiving the homeowner’s insurance deductible
30%
of modeled hail loss is in Texas, which has no state roofing credential
52% / 69%
reports / loss if Nebraska and Wisconsin count as no credential

1. Executive findings

About 43% of NOAA’s large-hail reports came from states that require no statewide license or registration for a typical residential re-roof. From 2015 to 2024, 42.6% of the 70,146 large-hail reports in NOAA’s Storm Events database came from these 15 states. Some of their largest cities license or register roofers locally (section 6). Measured by FEMA’s modeled expected annual hail loss to buildings, those states hold 60.5% of the $2.52 billion national total.

How this study defines a state credential

A state counts as having a credential if a contractor must hold a state-issued license or registration before contracting directly with a homeowner for a $10,000 re-roof on a one- or two-family home, anywhere in the state.

  • A registration with no exam counts. Exams, bonds and insurance are not part of the test.
  • A credential that applies only above $10,000, or only in some counties, does not count.
  • City licenses are not state credentials. They are covered separately in section 6.

Large hail means hail 1 inch or larger, the National Weather Service threshold for severe hail. A report is one entry in NOAA’s database, not one storm and not one damaged home.

The result depends on that definition, so we show how far it moves. Two states sit on the line. Nebraska requires only a $25 Department of Labor registration with no exam, and Wisconsin’s credential applies only to whoever pulls a permit. Counting both as having no credential raises the share to 52% of large-hail reports and 69% of modeled loss. Our main estimate keeps them in, so 43% and 61% are the conservative figures.

Main estimateIf Nebraska and Wisconsin count as no credential
States with no state credential1517
Share of NOAA large-hail reports, 2015–202442.6%51.7%
Share of FEMA modeled expected annual hail loss60.5%69%

The contract, not the contractor. Among the states with the greatest modeled hail losses, contract protections are more widespread than roofing-specific state credentials. Of the 10 states with the most modeled hail loss (74% of the national total), 8 ban contractors from waiving the homeowner’s insurance deductible and 7 let homeowners cancel a roofing contract after an insurer denies the claim. Only 4 of those 10 require a roofing-specific state credential, and 4 require none.

Texas is the clearest case. It has 15% of NOAA large-hail reports and 30% of the nation’s modeled hail loss. It bans deductible waivers but has no statewide roofing credential and no cancellation right tied to a claim denial.

This study measures laws on the books. It does not measure whether those laws reduce fraud or protect homeowners in practice (section 7).


2. Where hail exposure is concentrated

Hail risk is concentrated in a handful of states, and the largest of them have no state roofing credential. Ten states account for 74% of FEMA’s modeled expected annual hail loss to buildings. Texas alone accounts for 30%.

Reading the charts. “No state credential” means no state-issued license or registration is needed for a $10,000 re-roof of a one- or two-family home. A registration with no exam counts as a credential. A credential that applies only above $10,000 does not. City licenses are counted separately (section 6). This is a research classification, not a finding that any roofer is working illegally.

Figure 1. Top 15 jurisdictions by FEMA modeled hail loss, with state credential tierPaired horizontal bars for each state. The upper, colored bar is its share of FEMA modeled expected annual hail loss to buildings, colored by credential tier. The lower, gray bar is its share of NOAA large-hail reports, 2015 to 2024. Texas leads with 30.0% of modeled loss and 15.3% of reports.Share of national hail exposure, top 15 of 51 jurisdictionsTier 1, roofing-specificTier 2, generalTier 3, no state credentialColored bar: share of FEMA modeled hail loss (color = credential tier).Gray bar: share of NOAA large-hail reports, 2015–2024.0%8%16%24%32%Texas: Tier 3, no state credential. 30.0% of modeled hail loss; 15.3% of NOAA large-hail reports.Texas30.0%15.3%Colorado: Tier 3, no state credential. 12.2% of modeled hail loss; 5.3% of NOAA large-hail reports.Colorado12.2%5.3%Missouri: Tier 3, no state credential. 4.7% of modeled hail loss; 4.5% of NOAA large-hail reports.Missouri4.7%4.5%Wisconsin: Tier 2, general. 4.6% of modeled hail loss; 2.1% of NOAA large-hail reports.Wisconsin4.6%2.1%Oklahoma: Tier 1, roofing-specific. 4.4% of modeled hail loss; 6.0% of NOAA large-hail reports.Oklahoma4.4%6.0%Nebraska: Tier 2, general. 3.9% of modeled hail loss; 7.0% of NOAA large-hail reports.Nebraska3.9%7.0%Minnesota: Tier 1, roofing-specific. 3.9% of modeled hail loss; 4.4% of NOAA large-hail reports.Minnesota3.9%4.4%Ohio: Tier 3, no state credential. 3.7% of modeled hail loss; 1.4% of NOAA large-hail reports.Ohio3.7%1.4%Illinois: Tier 1, roofing-specific. 3.2% of modeled hail loss; 3.0% of NOAA large-hail reports.Illinois3.2%3.0%Kansas: Tier 1, roofing-specific. 3.0% of modeled hail loss; 8.9% of NOAA large-hail reports.Kansas3.0%8.9%Kentucky: Tier 3, no state credential. 2.4% of modeled hail loss; 1.3% of NOAA large-hail reports.Kentucky2.4%1.3%Iowa: Tier 2, general. 2.2% of modeled hail loss; 3.8% of NOAA large-hail reports.Iowa2.2%3.8%Michigan: Tier 1, roofing-specific. 2.1% of modeled hail loss; 0.9% of NOAA large-hail reports.Michigan2.1%0.9%Georgia: Tier 3, no state credential. 2.0% of modeled hail loss; 1.2% of NOAA large-hail reports.Georgia2.0%1.2%Indiana: Tier 3, no state credential. 1.9% of modeled hail loss; 1.5% of NOAA large-hail reports.Indiana1.9%1.5%NOAA NCEI Storm Events 2015–2024; FEMA National Risk Index v1.20 (Dec 2025); NumeralQ statute review as of 6 Nov 2026.
Figure 1. Share of FEMA modeled expected annual hail loss to buildings (colored bars, by state credential tier) and of NOAA large-hail reports, 2015–2024 (gray bars), for the 15 jurisdictions with the most modeled loss. Sources: NOAA NCEI Storm Events 2015–2024; FEMA National Risk Index v1.20 (Dec 2025); NumeralQ statute review as of 6 Nov 2026. Download SVG
Show the numbers behind this chart
StateCredential tierShare of modeled hail lossShare of NOAA large-hail reports
TexasTier 3, no state credential30.0%15.3%
ColoradoTier 3, no state credential12.2%5.3%
MissouriTier 3, no state credential4.7%4.5%
WisconsinTier 2, general4.6%2.1%
OklahomaTier 1, roofing-specific4.4%6.0%
NebraskaTier 2, general3.9%7.0%
MinnesotaTier 1, roofing-specific3.9%4.4%
OhioTier 3, no state credential3.7%1.4%
IllinoisTier 1, roofing-specific3.2%3.0%
KansasTier 1, roofing-specific3.0%8.9%
KentuckyTier 3, no state credential2.4%1.3%
IowaTier 2, general2.2%3.8%
MichiganTier 1, roofing-specific2.1%0.9%
GeorgiaTier 3, no state credential2.0%1.2%
IndianaTier 3, no state credential1.9%1.5%

The two exposure measures answer different questions. NOAA’s report count says where large hail was observed and logged. FEMA’s modeled loss weights that hazard by the value of buildings in its path, so it ranks populous, fast-growing metros higher. That is why Kansas and Nebraska rank high on reports but lower on loss, while Colorado and Texas rank high on both.

The two measures are not independent confirmations. FEMA builds its hail model partly from the same NOAA reports, and its loss figure covers homes and commercial buildings alike. We treat NOAA reports as the primary exposure measure and FEMA loss as a dollar-weighted view of the same hazard.


3. Who regulates roofing contractors?

Nineteen states require a roofing-specific state credential, 17 require a general contractor credential that covers roofing, and 15 require none. We sorted all 50 states and the District of Columbia into three tiers using the $10,000 re-roof test in section 1.

Figure 2. State credential tier for a $10,000 residential re-roof, all 50 states and DCTile map. 19 states require a roofing-specific state credential, 17 require a general contractor credential that covers roofing, and 15 require no state credential.State credential needed for a $10,000 re-roof of a one- or two-family homeTier 1, roofing-specific (19)Tier 2, general (17)Tier 3, no state credential (15)Alaska: Tier 2, generalAKT2Maine: Tier 3, no state credentialMET3Wisconsin: Tier 2, generalWIT2Vermont: Tier 2, generalVTT2New Hampshire: Tier 3, no state credentialNHT3Washington: Tier 2, generalWAT2Idaho: Tier 2, generalIDT2Montana: Tier 2, generalMTT2North Dakota: Tier 2, generalNDT2Minnesota: Tier 1, roofing-specificMNT1Illinois: Tier 1, roofing-specificILT1Michigan: Tier 1, roofing-specificMIT1New York: Tier 3, no state credentialNYT3Massachusetts: Tier 1, roofing-specificMAT1Oregon: Tier 2, generalORT2Nevada: Tier 1, roofing-specificNVT1Wyoming: Tier 3, no state credentialWYT3South Dakota: Tier 3, no state credentialSDT3Iowa: Tier 2, generalIAT2Indiana: Tier 3, no state credentialINT3Ohio: Tier 3, no state credentialOHT3Pennsylvania: Tier 2, generalPAT2New Jersey: Tier 2, generalNJT2Connecticut: Tier 2, generalCTT2Rhode Island: Tier 2, generalRIT2California: Tier 1, roofing-specificCAT1Utah: Tier 1, roofing-specificUTT1Colorado: Tier 3, no state credentialCOT3Nebraska: Tier 2, generalNET2Missouri: Tier 3, no state credentialMOT3Kentucky: Tier 3, no state credentialKYT3West Virginia: Tier 2, generalWVT2Virginia: Tier 1, roofing-specificVAT1Maryland: Tier 2, generalMDT2Delaware: Tier 3, no state credentialDET3Arizona: Tier 1, roofing-specificAZT1New Mexico: Tier 1, roofing-specificNMT1Kansas: Tier 1, roofing-specificKST1Arkansas: Tier 1, roofing-specificART1Tennessee: Tier 3, no state credentialTNT3North Carolina: Tier 3, no state credentialNCT3South Carolina: Tier 1, roofing-specificSCT1District of Columbia: Tier 2, generalDCT2Oklahoma: Tier 1, roofing-specificOKT1Louisiana: Tier 1, roofing-specificLAT1Mississippi: Tier 1, roofing-specificMST1Alabama: Tier 1, roofing-specificALT1Georgia: Tier 3, no state credentialGAT3Hawaii: Tier 1, roofing-specificHIT1Texas: Tier 3, no state credentialTXT3Florida: Tier 1, roofing-specificFLT1NumeralQ statute and licensing-board review of all 50 states and DC, as of 6 Nov 2026. T1, T2, T3 = tier.
Figure 2. State credential tier for a $10,000 re-roof of a one- or two-family home. Source: NumeralQ statute and licensing-board review of all 50 states and DC, as of 6 Nov 2026. Per-state sources are in state-rules.csv. Download SVG
Show the numbers behind this chart
TierStatesJurisdictions
Tier 1, roofing-specific19Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Florida, Hawaii, Illinois, Kansas, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Nevada, New Mexico, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Utah, Virginia
Tier 2, general17Alaska, Connecticut, District of Columbia, Idaho, Iowa, Maryland, Montana, Nebraska, New Jersey, North Dakota, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin
Tier 3, no state credential15Colorado, Delaware, Georgia, Indiana, Kentucky, Maine, Missouri, New Hampshire, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Wyoming
  • Tier 1, roofing-specific (19): a roofing license, classification or registration issued by the state.
  • Tier 2, general (17): a general contractor or home-improvement license or registration that covers roofing.
  • Tier 3, no state credential (15): no state credential applies to a $10,000 residential re-roof.

A few placements need explaining:

  • North Carolina and Tennessee license general contractors, but only above $40,000 and $25,000 respectively, so a $10,000 re-roof falls under the line.
  • Georgia licenses residential contractors, but roofers are treated as specialty contractors exempt from that license (O.C.G.A. 43-41-17).
  • Nebraska requires only a $25 Department of Labor registration with no exam. Wisconsin’s credential attaches to whoever pulls a building permit, and some towns don’t require a permit for a re-roof. Both are counted as Tier 2 and tested as Tier 3 in the sensitivity check.
  • Texas has no state roofing credential. A 2025 bill to license re-roofers (HB 3344) died in committee.

The most complete prior survey of these laws is the National Insurance Crime Bureau’s State Roofing Contractor Laws Compendium (December 2022). We used it as a starting point, checked every row against current statutes and board sources, and corrected it where it had changed or was incomplete.


4. The contract, not the contractor: what protections homeowners have

Twenty-three states ban roofers from waiving a homeowner’s insurance deductible, and those states account for 73% of NOAA large-hail reports and 84% of modeled hail loss. Twenty-three states also let a homeowner cancel a roofing contract after an insurer denies the claim. Among the states with the greatest modeled hail losses, these contract protections are more widespread than roofing-specific state credentials.

Figure 3. Ten states with the most modeled hail loss: contract protections and state credentialsFor the 10 states with the most FEMA modeled hail loss (74% of the national total), 8 ban deductible waivers, 7 allow cancellation after a claim denial, 4 require a roofing-specific state credential and 4 require none.Top 10 states by modeled hail loss: credential vs. contract protectionsFilled circle = protection in force on 6 Nov 2026. Open circle = none. Credential is colored by tier.Share of modeled lossState credentialDeductible-waiver banCancel after claim denialTexas: 30.0% of modeled hail loss. Credential: Tier 3, no state credential. Deductible-waiver ban: yes. Cancel after claim denial: no.Texas30%NoneYesNoColorado: 12.2% of modeled hail loss. Credential: Tier 3, no state credential. Deductible-waiver ban: yes. Cancel after claim denial: yes.Colorado12%NoneYesYesMissouri: 4.7% of modeled hail loss. Credential: Tier 3, no state credential. Deductible-waiver ban: yes. Cancel after claim denial: yes.Missouri5%NoneYesYesWisconsin: 4.6% of modeled hail loss. Credential: Tier 2, general. Deductible-waiver ban: yes. Cancel after claim denial: yes.Wisconsin5%GeneralYesYesOklahoma: 4.4% of modeled hail loss. Credential: Tier 1, roofing-specific. Deductible-waiver ban: yes. Cancel after claim denial: yes.Oklahoma4%Roofing-specificYesYesNebraska: 3.9% of modeled hail loss. Credential: Tier 2, general. Deductible-waiver ban: yes. Cancel after claim denial: yes.Nebraska4%GeneralYesYesMinnesota: 3.9% of modeled hail loss. Credential: Tier 1, roofing-specific. Deductible-waiver ban: yes. Cancel after claim denial: yes.Minnesota4%Roofing-specificYesYesOhio: 3.7% of modeled hail loss. Credential: Tier 3, no state credential. Deductible-waiver ban: no. Cancel after claim denial: no.Ohio4%NoneNoNoIllinois: 3.2% of modeled hail loss. Credential: Tier 1, roofing-specific. Deductible-waiver ban: yes. Cancel after claim denial: yes.Illinois3%Roofing-specificYesYesKansas: 3.0% of modeled hail loss. Credential: Tier 1, roofing-specific. Deductible-waiver ban: no. Cancel after claim denial: no.Kansas3%Roofing-specificNoNochart-data-by-state.csv · FEMA National Risk Index v1.20; NumeralQ statute review as of 6 Nov 2026.
Figure 3. The 10 states with the most modeled hail loss (74% of the national total): state credential tier and the two contract protections. Source: chart-data-by-state.csv (from state-hail-and-rules.csv); FEMA NRI v1.20; NumeralQ statute review as of 6 Nov 2026. Download SVG
Show the numbers behind this chart
StateShare of modeled hail lossState credentialDeductible-waiver banCancel after claim denial
Texas30.0%Tier 3, no state credentialYesNo
Colorado12.2%Tier 3, no state credentialYesYes
Missouri4.7%Tier 3, no state credentialYesYes
Wisconsin4.6%Tier 2, generalYesYes
Oklahoma4.4%Tier 1, roofing-specificYesYes
Nebraska3.9%Tier 2, generalYesYes
Minnesota3.9%Tier 1, roofing-specificYesYes
Ohio3.7%Tier 3, no state credentialNoNo
Illinois3.2%Tier 1, roofing-specificYesYes
Kansas3.0%Tier 1, roofing-specificNoNo

We counted two protections, and only when a statute names contractors or sellers:

  • Deductible-waiver ban: a contractor may not pay, waive or rebate the homeowner’s insurance deductible. General insurance-fraud laws are not counted.
  • Cancellation after claim denial: the homeowner may cancel a roofing contract within a set time after the insurer denies all or part of the claim. General 3-day door-to-door or home-improvement cancellation rights are not counted, because they run from signing and have nothing to do with the claim.
Credential tierStatesDeductible banCancel after denialBothNeither
Tier 1, roofing-specific1991088
Tier 2, general1754412
Tier 3, no state credential159985
All5123232025

The states with no state credential are not the states with no protections. Nine of the 15 ban deductible waivers, as many as in Tier 1. Only five (Delaware, Maine, New Hampshire, North Carolina and Ohio) have no credential and neither protection, and together they account for 4% of NOAA large-hail reports and 5% of modeled loss.

The reverse case is Kansas. It registers roofers statewide under its Roofing Registration Act but has neither contract protection. We read all 18 sections of the act to confirm this.

Our recheck changed several rows from the 2022 compendium. It missed deductible bans already in force in Arizona, Georgia, New York, Utah and West Virginia, and Mississippi added one in 2024. In each case we read the statute or enacted bill. Florida’s 10-day cancellation right applies only after a declared emergency and is not tied to a claim denial, so we count it as no.

Virginia’s deductible ban (Va. Code 59.1-618) takes effect on 1 January 2027, after our cutoff, so it is counted as not yet in force. If it takes effect as scheduled, the count rises to 24.

The legal detail for each of the 26 states with at least one counted protection is in Appendix A.


5. Texas: the outlier

Texas carries more hail risk than any other state and regulates the storm-repair transaction, not the roofer. It has 8% of the nation’s homes but 30% of FEMA’s modeled hail loss, 15% of NOAA large-hail reports and one in five reports of hail 1.75 inches or larger.

Figure 4. Texas's share of U.S. homes, hail reports and modeled hail lossTexas has 8.4% of U.S. homes, 15.3% of NOAA large-hail reports, 20.5% of reports of hail 1.75 inches or larger and 30.0% of FEMA modeled hail loss.Texas as a share of the U.S. total0%8%16%24%32%Texas: 8.4% of U.S. homes (Census ACS 2020–2024 (B25001))U.S. homesCensus ACS 2020–2024 (B25001)8.4%Texas: 15.3% of NOAA large-hail reports (1 in.+) (NOAA Storm Events 2015–2024)NOAA large-hail reports (1 in.+)NOAA Storm Events 2015–202415.3%Texas: 20.5% of NOAA reports of hail 1.75 in.+ (NOAA Storm Events 2015–2024)NOAA reports of hail 1.75 in.+NOAA Storm Events 2015–202420.5%Texas: 30.0% of FEMA modeled annual hail loss (FEMA NRI v1.20)FEMA modeled annual hail lossFEMA NRI v1.2030.0%NOAA NCEI Storm Events 2015–2024; FEMA National Risk Index v1.20; Census ACS 2020–2024 5-year (B25001).
Figure 4. Texas as a share of the U.S. total on four measures. Sources: NOAA NCEI Storm Events 2015–2024; FEMA National Risk Index v1.20; Census ACS 2020–2024 5-year (B25001). Download SVG
Show the numbers behind this chart
MeasureTexas share of U.S. totalSource
U.S. homes8.4%Census ACS 2020–2024 (B25001)
NOAA large-hail reports (1 in.+)15.3%NOAA Storm Events 2015–2024
NOAA reports of hail 1.75 in.+20.5%NOAA Storm Events 2015–2024
FEMA modeled annual hail loss30.0%FEMA NRI v1.20

Texas does protect homeowners. Its protections target the insurance-paid roofing transaction rather than who may do the work. The four rules below are kept separate because they are often run together.

RuleTexas, as of 6 Nov 2026Source
State roofer license or registrationNone. The Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation does not regulate roofing. HB 3344 (2025), a bill to license re-roofers, died in committee in May 2025.Texas Legislature Online bill history
Deductible-waiver banYes. A contractor paid from a property insurance claim may not waive, pay or rebate the deductible. Contracts of $1,000 or more must carry a required notice.Bus. & Com. Code 27.02; Ins. Code 707.002
Cancellation after claim denialNone. 23 states have this right. Texas does not.Statute search; Texas State Law Library
General 3-day cancellationOnly when the contractor solicits the sale and the homeowner signs away from the contractor’s place of business, such as at home, for more than $25 (601.002). The homeowner may cancel until midnight of the third business day after signing, whatever happens with the claim (601.051). The federal Cooling-Off Rule is similar but lets a buyer waive the right in a buyer-initiated emergency. The Texas chapter has no emergency exception and bars contract waivers (601.151).Bus. & Com. Code 601.002, 601.051, 601.151; 16 CFR 429.0 (both read 6 Nov 2026)

The gap is specific. A Texas homeowner is protected from a roofer who offers to absorb the deductible. A homeowner who signs a roofing contract before the insurer decides the claim, and is then denied, has no claim-specific right to cancel. They have only the general 3-day right. It applies only if the contract was solicited and signed away from the contractor’s office, and it runs from signing, so it often expires before the insurer decides.

Large Texas cities add their own rules, but they are registrations, not tested licenses (section 6).


6. The local licensing patchwork

In states with no state credential, roofer oversight often changes at the city line. Several major cities in Colorado, South Dakota and Wyoming impose their own roofing contractor licenses, although the evidence is stronger in some markets than others (Rapid City’s license is reported but not confirmed). The largest Texas cities only register contractors or require a permit, and no checked Texas city requires a tested roofing license.

We reviewed 21 large markets in five no-credential states with heavy hail exposure. A city rule was documented for 16 of them. Four Texas suburbs were not checked, and one market is unincorporated. All 21 are listed below.

StateMarketsResearch statusWhat the city requiresShare of the state’s homes
ColoradoDenver, Colorado Springs, Fort Collins (3)CheckedCity or regional roofing contractor license; exams reported in all three25%
South DakotaSioux Falls, Rapid City (2)CheckedSioux Falls: roofing license with exam. Rapid City: roofing license reported, not confirmed.31%
WyomingCheyenne, Casper (2)CheckedCity roofing contractor license; Casper requires testing21%
TexasDallas, Fort Worth, San Antonio, Austin, Arlington (5)CheckedCity contractor registration to pull a permit. San Antonio adds an FBI background check. No exam found.18%
TexasHouston, Plano (2)CheckedRe-roof permit required; no contractor registration found10%
MissouriKansas City (1)CheckedCity residential building contractor license for permits; coverage of roofing not confirmed9%
MissouriSt. Louis (1)CheckedBusiness license only; no trade test found6%
TexasFrisco, McKinney, Round Rock, Sugar Land (4)Not checkedNot researched2%
TexasThe Woodlands (1)Not applicableUnincorporated, so no city government to license or register roofers0.4%

Shares are housing units inside each city’s Census place boundary (ACS 2020–2024), divided by the state total. They describe how much of the state’s housing sits inside the listed market boundaries. They are not estimates of the share of housing legally covered by a local licensing requirement, especially where a rule is unconfirmed or is a registration or permit rather than a license.

What this does not show. Suburbs, small towns and unincorporated areas were not surveyed, so this study cannot estimate the share of homes nationally, or in any state, covered by a local roofing license. The finding is limited to the largest cities.


7. What the findings do and do not mean

This study measures which laws are on the books where hail falls. It does not measure whether those laws work.

The findings support these statements:

  • A large share of US hail exposure falls in states that do not require a state credential for a typical residential re-roof.
  • Among the states with the greatest modeled hail losses, contract protections (deductible bans and claim-denial cancellation rights) are more widespread than roofing-specific state credentials.
  • Texas has the largest share of exposure and pairs a deductible ban with no state credential and no claim-denial cancellation right.

The findings do not support these statements:

  • That roofers in Tier 3 states are “unlicensed.” Many hold city licenses or registrations, and the term implies wrongdoing.
  • That a state credential reduces fraud, or that homeowners in Tier 3 states are more likely to be victimized. We have no complaint, enforcement or outcome data.
  • Any count of hailstorms or damaged homes. NOAA counts reports, which lean toward populated areas. FEMA’s figure is modeled loss to all buildings, not observed damage to homes.

Limitations

  1. The result depends on the credential definition. Moving Nebraska and Wisconsin to Tier 3 raises the share to 52% of NOAA large-hail reports and 69% of modeled loss. Keeping Georgia in Tier 2 lowers it to 41% and 58%.
  2. Some legal classifications are less certain. Two kinds of rows are rated low confidence, and they affect different results. Six credential classifications (Delaware, DC, Montana, New York, Vermont, Wisconsin) are low confidence. Together these jurisdictions account for about 5% of NOAA large-hail reports and 5% of modeled loss, so reclassifying them could move the exposure percentages by up to about 5 points. Three contract-protection classifications (Arkansas, DC, Michigan) are low confidence. These affect the counts of states with deductible bans and claim-denial cancellation rights, not the hail-exposure percentages. Each is identified in the data files.
  3. Some statutes were read from secondary text. Indiana, Illinois, Louisiana, Oklahoma and Mississippi came from agency material and excerpts rather than official code pages. The Tennessee and Arkansas deductible rules could not be read in official text; both are counted as no ban.
  4. Local coverage is partial. The city layer covers 21 large markets in five states, not every market in every state.
  5. The two exposure measures overlap. FEMA’s hail model draws partly on the same NOAA reports, so they are two views of one hazard, not independent confirmations.

8. Methodology and sources

Research cutoff: 6 November 2026. Laws are classified as in force on that date. Hail data cover 2015 through 2024. The findings and data files were frozen on 6 November 2026.

Exposure. We counted every NOAA Storm Events hail record in a county from 2015 to 2024 with hail of at least 1 inch (70,146 reports) and at least 1.75 inches (19,526). A hail day is a county with at least one such report on a given date (35,588). FEMA’s National Risk Index v1.20 (December 2025) supplied each county’s modeled expected annual hail loss to buildings ($2.52 billion nationally) and its hail-loss rating. Housing units come from the Census Bureau’s American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates (table B25001). All 3,232 US counties and county equivalents are included. State shares are simple sums of county values.

Credentials. Each state was classified with the $10,000 re-roof test in section 1, using state statutes and licensing-board material. Every row records its source and a high, medium or low confidence rating: 20 rows are high, 25 medium and 6 low.

Protections. A deductible ban or claim-denial cancellation right counts only when a statute names contractors or sellers. We read current statute text directly for Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Iowa, Kansas, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, New York, North Dakota, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, Utah, West Virginia and Wyoming, and enacted bill text for Alabama, Arizona, Georgia, Kentucky and New Jersey. Other states were checked against the NICB compendium and current searches.

Local rules. City and county pages for the 21 markets in section 6, with secondary sources where official pages could not be reached. Each city’s source and confidence is in the data files.

Independence. No input comes from NumeralQ’s pricing model or cost data.

Scheduled legal check, around 1 February 2027. A few laws in this study change or take effect in early 2027, including Virginia’s deductible ban (1 January 2027) and pending bills in Illinois (HB 4738) and Wisconsin (SB 531). We will recheck those rows, the rows marked “February check” in Appendix A and the low-confidence rows in section 7. If a classification changes, we will recalculate the totals and charts from the data files and note the change and its date on this page. The hail data and the research cutoff will not change.

After that check, the paper stays fixed as a dated research report with the November 2026 cutoff. It will not be updated as laws change.

Sources

  • NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information, Storm Events Database, bulk detail files 2015–2024 (revised March to July 2026).
  • FEMA, National Risk Index, v1.20, December 2025, county hail fields.
  • U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates, table B25001.
  • National Insurance Crime Bureau, State Roofing Contractor Laws Compendium, December 2022.
  • State statutes, enacted bills and licensing-board pages, listed per state in the data files.

Download the data

Every chart on this page is computed directly from chart-data-by-state.csv, a column extract of state-hail-and-rules.csv. Each file is the frozen 6 November 2026 version; SHA256SUMS.txt lets you confirm a file is unchanged.

This is a research classification of laws on the books, not legal advice. Check with the state licensing board or a lawyer before relying on any row.


Appendix A. Contract protections by state

This table shows what each of the 26 states counted in section 4 requires, as read on 6 November 2026. Twenty-three have a deductible ban and 23 have a claim-denial cancellation right. The same table is in contract-protections-appendix.csv.

Two phrases mean different things. “Not specified” means we read the provision and it does not address the point. “Not in source read” means our source was a summary or excerpt, so the point is unknown, not absent. Nothing in this table is inferred.

The Source status column shows how strong the evidence is for each row:

  • Verified statutory text (15 states): we read the provision itself, in current code or the enacted act.
  • Verified but conditional (3 states): we read the provision, but whether it applies depends on circumstances (Alabama, Arizona, Texas).
  • Summary-only (8 states): the classification rests on the 2022 NICB compendium or other secondary text.

Rows marked “February check” are part of the scheduled legal check around 1 February 2027. The national totals stay as published here unless that check changes a classification. If it does, the totals and charts are recalculated from the data files.

StateCountedSource statusCitationEnacted or effective (as read)ScopeCancellation period and triggerPartial denial qualifiesExceptionsSource readConfidence
ALCancelVerified but conditional (window may start at signing); February checkAla. Code 8-36-22012 HB 405 (takes effect the first day of the third month after passage); 2019 amendment (Act 2019-99) not readResidential roofing contractors (1–4 family homes); insurance-paid work5 business days after signing, if the insurer has sent written notice of non-coverage. The bill copy read shows an edit between "fifth" and "tenth"; enacted figure to confirmYes ("all or any part")Contractor may collect for emergency services the owner acknowledged in writing2012 bill textMedium
AZBan, cancelVerified but conditional (insurer-designated storm areas only); February checkA.R.S. 32-1158.02(B), (C), (J)Amended 2026 ch. 157 (SB 1206); effective date not stated in text readLicensed contractors repairing storm damage in an insurer-designated catastrophic-storm area, owner-occupied homes72 hours after notice that the claim was denied; plus a separate 4-business-day cancel for any reason after signingNot specifiedReasonable pay for itemized emergency services; no work before the insurer decides except to prevent further lossCurrent statuteHigh
ARCancelSummary-only; February checkA.C.A. 4-88-903, 4-88-904Not in source readInsurance-paid residential roofing (per NICB)3 business days after written notice that all or part of the claim is not coveredYesNot in source read; contractor may not start work until the right expiresNICB 2022 summaryLow
COBan, cancelVerified statutory textC.R.S. 6-22-104 (rescind), 6-22-105 (ban)Not stated in text readResidential roofing work paid from property and casualty insurance72 hours after written notice of denialYes ("in whole or in part")Does not apply to denial of unforeseeable supplemental work; contractor may recover value of materials installedCurrent statute (official text mirror)High
FLBanVerified statutory textFla. Stat. 489.147(2)(b)Ch. 2021-77; amended 2022, 2024, 2025Contractors; bans offering a deductible waiver or other value in exchange for a roof inspection or an insurance claimNot counted. A separate 10-day cancel applies only after a declared emergency and is not tied to a denialNot applicableNot specifiedCurrent statuteHigh
GABan, cancelVerified statutory textO.C.G.A. 10-1-393.122011 HB 423; effective date not stated in text readResidential roofing contractors; insurance-paid workMidnight of the 5th business day after written noticeYes ("all or any part")Contractor may collect for emergency services acknowledged in writing; no payment due until the period ends2011 bill as passedMedium
ILBan, cancelSummary-only; February check815 ILCS 513/18Not in source read; HB 4738 pendingHome repair and remodeling contractors; insurance-paid workThe earlier of the 5th business day after written notice or the 13th business day after the insurer receives proof of lossYes ("all or any part")Not in source readNICB 2022 + IDFPR brochureMedium
INBan, cancelSummary-only; February checkIC 24-5-11-10 (cancel), 24-5-11-10.5 (ban)Not in source readProperty improvement suppliersMidnight of the 3rd business day after written noticeYes ("all or any part")Not in source readNICB 2022 + secondary excerptsMedium
IABanVerified statutory textIowa Code 103A.71(2), (4)Not stated in text readContractors doing roof or exterior repair after a catastrophe; ban applies to any sale, not only insurance-paidNot counted. No claim-denial cancel; contract is void if the contractor rebates or negotiates the claimNot applicableItems of nominal value; signs displayed with consent and no paymentCurrent statuteHigh
KYBan, cancelVerified statutory textKRS 367.620 to 367.6282012 Acts ch. 97; applies to contracts on or after the act's effective date (date not stated in text read)Roofing contractors, residential roof systems; insurance-paid workMidnight of the 5th business day after written noticeYes ("all or part")Contractor may collect a reasonable amount for repairs the owner authorized, including to prevent further damage2012 enacted actMedium
LABan, cancelSummary-only; February checkLa. R.S. 37:2175.1 (cancel); R.S. 51:451, 51:452 (ban)Not in source readHome improvement contractors, roof systems; insurance-paid work. Contracts of $1,000+ need a deductible notice72 hours after notice that all or part of the claim is deniedYes ("all or any part")Not in source readNICB 2022 summaryMedium
MNBan, cancelVerified statutory textMinn. Stat. 325E.66 (ban), 326B.811 (cancel)2010 c 324; last amended 2024 (325E.66) and 2015 (326B.811)Residential contractors, remodelers and roofers; insurance-paid work72 hours after notice that the claim was deniedNot specifiedContractor is paid for emergency servicesCurrent statuteHigh
MSBan, cancelSummary-only; February checkMiss. Code 75-24-307 (cancel); ban added by 2024 HB 1408Ban effective 1 July 2024 (per legislative record); ban section text not readResidential roof system repair; insurance-paid work3 business days after written notice that all or part is not coveredYes ("all or part")No pay for work begun before the right expires if the contract is canceledNICB 2022 + bill recordMedium
MOBan, cancelVerified statutory textRSMo 407.725L. 2011 SB 101; amended 2014 SB 610; current text effective 28 Aug 2014Roof and exterior contractors, residential and commercial property. Ban applies to any sale; cancel to insurance-paid workMidnight of the 5th business day after written noticeYes ("all or any part")Contractor is paid for emergency servicesCurrent statuteHigh
NEBan, cancelVerified statutory textNeb. Rev. Stat. 44-8603 (cancel), 44-8604 (ban), 44-8607 (notice)Laws 2012 LB 943; notice added by Laws 2018 LB 743Residential contractors; insurance-paid workMidnight of the later of the 3rd business day after signing or after written noticeYes ("all or part")Pay for work agreed in writing as needed to prevent damage; items of nominal value exempt from the banCurrent statuteHigh
NYBan, cancelVerified statutory textN.Y. Gen. Bus. Law 771-b(2), (3)Revision in force since 29 May 2020 (NY Senate site); earlier revision 2019Roofing contractors; insurance-paid workMidnight of the 3rd business day after written noticeYes ("all or any part")No cancel right if the owner started contact for a genuine emergency and signs a handwritten waiver; reasonable value of acknowledged emergency servicesCurrent statuteHigh
NDBan, cancelVerified statutory textN.D.C.C. 26.1-39.2-02 (cancel), -03 (ban)Not stated in text readResidential contractors; insurance-paid workMidnight of the later of the 5th business day after signing or after written noticeYes ("all or part")Pay for work agreed in writing as needed to prevent damage; contract void if the contractor violates the chapterCurrent statuteHigh
OKBan, cancelSummary-only; February check59 O.S. 1151.21 (cancel), 1151.30 (ban)Ban: HB 1940, effective 1 Nov 2022 (per bill text)Residential contractors; ban also covers commercial roofing contractors72 hours after written notice that all or any part is deniedYes ("all or any part")Not in source readBill text + NICB 2022Medium
SCBan, cancelVerified statutory textS.C. Code 40-59-25(A) (cancel), (E) (ban)2013 Act No. 77, effective 1 July 2013Licensed builders, registered specialty contractors and unregistered persons doing that work; roofing systems; insurance-paidMidnight of the 5th business day after written noticeYes ("all or part")Contractor is paid for emergency services; no payment due until the period endsCurrent statuteHigh
SDBan, cancelVerified statutory textSDCL 37-24-50 (ban), 37-24-51 (cancel)SL 2012 ch. 198Ban: any residential roofing contractor. Cancel: written storm-damage roofing contracts72 hours after signing, or 72 hours after notice of denialYes ("in whole or in part")Refund covers only goods and services not yet performed; contract void if the ban is brokenCurrent statuteHigh
TNCancelSummary-only; February checkTenn. Code 62-6-602, 62-6-603Not in source readInsurance-paid roofing contracts (per NICB)Midnight of the 3rd business day after written noticeYes ("all or any part")Not in source readNICB 2022 summaryMedium
TXBanVerified but conditional (only without insurer consent); February checkTex. Bus. & Com. Code 27.02; Ins. Code 707.00227.02 amended by 2019 HB 2102, effective 1 Sep 2019Any seller paid wholly or partly from a property insurance claim; contracts of $1,000+ need a deductible noticeNot counted. No claim-denial cancel rightNot applicableThe offense applies only "without the insurer's consent"Current statuteHigh
UTBan, cancelVerified statutory textUtah Code 13-50-202 (cancel), 13-50-302 (ban)Cancel: 2013 ch. 160. Ban: 2020 ch. 88Residential contractors, where the contractor knew or should have known insurance would payWritten notice within 5 business days after notice that any part is deniedYes ("any part")Contractor keeps the value of work the owner told it to start before the insurer decidedCurrent statuteHigh
WVBan, cancelVerified statutory textW. Va. Code 46A-6M-2 (cancel), 46A-6M-5 (ban)Contracts on or after 1 July 2015 (2015 HB 2395)Roofing contractors, residential roof systems; insurance-paid workMidnight of the 5th business day after noticeYes ("all or part")Emergency repairs under 46A-6M-4 (section title only read)Current statuteHigh
WIBan, cancelSummary-only; February checkWis. Stat. 100.652013 Act 24; SB 531 pendingResidential contractors; roof and other exterior workMidnight of the 3rd business day after written noticeYes ("in whole or in part")Not in source readNICB 2022 + actMedium
WYBan, cancelVerified statutory textWyo. Stat. 40-12-702(c)(i) (ban), 40-12-705 (cancel)Not stated in text readExterior storm-damage repair contractors3 business days after signing or, if insurance-paid, 3 business days after written denial, whichever is laterYes ("in whole or in part")Owner may waive in writing once the insurer approves the claim; contractors may pass on ordinary discountsCurrent statuteHigh

Three rows change how the counts should be described:

  • Alabama: the 2012 text runs the 5-day window from signing, not from the denial, and the bill copy we read shows an edit between “fifth” and “tenth”. We did not read the 2019 amendment. Alabama stays counted and is on the scheduled legal check.
  • Arizona: both protections apply only to repairs in an insurer-designated catastrophic-storm area, not statewide.
  • Texas: the deductible ban applies only when the waiver happens without the insurer’s consent.

About the author

Joshua Kurz is Founder & Publisher of NumeralQ.