How Roof Insurance Claims Work in 2026

ACV vs. RCV Coverage: The Most Important Thing to Know

Before anything else, understand which type of coverage your policy provides — it determines your out-of-pocket cost by thousands of dollars.

Coverage Type	What It Pays	Your Out-of-Pocket	Example ($15,000 roof, 15 yr old)
RCV (Replacement Cost Value)	Full replacement cost	Deductible only	Insurer pays $14,000; you pay $1,000 deductible
ACV (Actual Cash Value)	Depreciated value	Deductible + depreciation	Insurer pays $6,000; you pay $1,000 deductible + $8,000 depreciation = $9,000 total

RCV policies cost more in annual premiums ($200–$600/yr more is typical), but after a major claim, the math is usually overwhelming in their favor. If you have an ACV policy, you should check your policy at renewal — switching to RCV is often straightforward for homes with well-maintained roofs.

Age-based exclusions: Many insurers now exclude roofs over 15–20 years old from RCV coverage regardless of your policy type, automatically dropping them to ACV. Some carriers in hail-prone markets have stopped offering RCV coverage for asphalt shingles entirely. Review your current policy declarations page now — before you need a claim.

Step-by-Step: Filing a Roof Claim

Step 1: Document the Damage Immediately

Photograph everything from ground level and, if safe, from the roof — before any emergency repairs. Date-stamped photos from your phone create valuable evidence. If the damage occurred during a storm, note the date and cross-reference weather records (Weather Underground and NOAA maintain historical storm data that adjusters use). Insurance requires you to prevent further damage ("duty to mitigate") — secure tarps or temporary repairs as needed. Keep all receipts.

Step 2: Get a Contractor Assessment Before Calling

Before filing, get an honest assessment from a licensed local roofing contractor. Some damage isn't severe enough to warrant a claim (especially if it's below your deductible), and a claim that pays out less than your deductible — or that you later withdraw — may still be counted as a filed claim in some states, affecting your premiums or coverage eligibility. A qualified contractor can tell you whether the damage meets the threshold for a valid claim.

Step 3: File the Claim

Contact your insurer via your app, website, or claims hotline. Provide: date of loss, description of damage, photos. You'll be assigned a claim number and an adjuster will be scheduled. Response time: 3–14 days in normal conditions; 3–8 weeks after major regional weather events when adjusters are overwhelmed.

Step 4: The Adjuster Inspection

Have your roofing contractor present during the adjuster inspection. This is legal, common, and in your best interest. A contractor who routinely works insurance claims knows exactly what items are typically included in Xactimate (the industry standard estimating software adjusters use) and can flag missing items on the spot. Common items that get omitted on first assessment: pipe boot replacements, ridge cap, hip and ridge shingles, drip edge replacement, permit costs, and code upgrade items.

Step 5: Review the Scope of Loss

The adjuster produces a written "scope of loss" document listing every item and its Xactimate pricing. Review it with your contractor. If items are missing or quantities are wrong, your contractor submits a supplemental claim with supporting documentation. Supplementing is routine — 10–30% of initial assessments are adjusted upward through legitimate supplements.

Step 6: Payment Structure (RCV Policies)

RCV policies typically pay in two stages:

1. Initial payment (ACV): The insurer sends a check for the depreciated value minus your deductible. This is the "actual cash value" portion.
2. Recoverable depreciation: After the work is completed and you submit proof of completion, the insurer releases the "recoverable depreciation" — the held-back amount that brings your payment to the full replacement cost.

Do not sign over the recoverable depreciation to a contractor as "assignment of benefits" (AOB) — this practice, while legal in some states, removes your control over the claim and has led to abusive litigation in Florida's market.

Red Flags to Avoid

• Deductible waiver offers: Illegal in most states. Any contractor offering to "cover your deductible," "work with insurance to make it disappear," or bill the insurer for the deductible amount is committing insurance fraud. This can void your coverage and expose you to legal liability.
• High-pressure post-storm solicitations: Storm chasers — contractors who follow weather events and go door-to-door — are often out-of-state companies that will disappear after installation. Use local, licensed, established contractors with verifiable reviews.
• Signing anything immediately: Never sign an Assignment of Benefits, direction to pay, or authorization for repairs without reading it carefully and understanding what you're authorizing. Have your attorney review AOB documents if you're unsure.
• Contracts that tie payment to insurance approval: "We'll only charge what insurance pays" sounds good but is a red flag — it means the contractor is working for the insurance company, not for you.

Related Cost Guides