RB-2026-004 Heat Pump or Gas? Winter Heating Costs in 146 U.S. Cities NumeralQ, https://www.numeralq.com/research/heat-pump-vs-gas-heating-costs Author: Joshua Kurz. Data frozen 17 November 2026. License: CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Credit "NumeralQ". These are MODELED running costs for one reference home (heat loss 400 Btu/hr per deg F) at EIA state-average residential prices in a typical-weather winter (NOAA 1991-2020 normals). They are not utility bills and exclude equipment and installation costs. "Winter" = October through March. Dollars are per winter, rounded to $1. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- city-heating-costs.csv (147 rows, one per city) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- city, state City and two-letter state. station_id, station_name, station_km NOAA normals station used (GHCN id), its name and distance from the city point (km). heating_degree_days_65f Annual normal heating degree days, base 65 F (sum of monthly normals). coldest_month_normal_low_f Lowest monthly normal daily minimum temperature (F). reference_home_heat_mmbtu Heat the reference home needs in a normal winter (million Btu) = 400 x 24 x HDD / 1e6. hp_seasonal_cop_standard Seasonal COP of the standard heat pump (incl. backup resistance). hp_seasonal_cop_cold_climate Seasonal COP of the cold-climate heat pump. elec_cents_kwh_winter_2025_26 State residential electricity price, Oct 2025-Mar 2026, sales-weighted (cents/kWh). gas_usd_mcf_winter_2025_26 State residential natural gas price, Oct 2025-Mar 2026, volume-weighted ($ per thousand cubic feet). elec_cents_kwh_winter_2023_24 Same, Oct 2023-Mar 2024. gas_usd_mcf_winter_2023_24 Same, Oct 2023-Mar 2024. cost_gas_furnace_95_2025_26 95% AFUE gas furnace incl. blower electricity (9 kWh per million Btu of heat), $. cost_gas_furnace_80_2025_26 80% AFUE gas furnace (older unit), same method, $. cost_heat_pump_cold_climate_2025_26 Cold-climate heat pump, $. cost_heat_pump_standard_2025_26 Standard heat pump with backup resistance, $. cost_electric_resistance_2025_26 Electric furnace or baseboard (COP 1.0), $. heat_pump_model_in_result_2025_26 Heat pump used in the headline: the one that costs less to run (cold-climate in every city). cost_best_heat_pump_2025_26 Cost of that heat pump, $. heat_pump_minus_gas_2025_26 cost_best_heat_pump minus cost_gas_furnace_95. Negative = heat pump cheaper. result_category_2025_26 clear heat pump advantage (< -50) | toss-up, heat pump slightly cheaper (-50 to below 0) | toss-up, equal cost (exactly 0) | toss-up, gas slightly cheaper (0 to 50) | clear gas advantage (> 50) | no heating season. standard_heat_pump_minus_gas_2025_26 Same difference using the standard heat pump. standard_heat_pump_category_2025_26 Same categories using the standard heat pump. saving_resistance_to_heat_pump_2025_26 cost_electric_resistance minus cost_best_heat_pump, $. saving_old_gas_to_heat_pump_2025_26 cost_gas_furnace_80 minus cost_best_heat_pump, $. *_2023_24 cost columns Same models at winter 2023-24 prices. heat_pump_minus_gas_2023_24 Best heat pump minus 95% gas furnace at winter 2023-24 prices. gas_furnace_cost_change_pct Change in 95% gas furnace cost, winter 2023-24 to 2025-26 (%). heat_pump_cost_change_pct Change in best heat pump cost, same winters (%). Honolulu has no heating season: costs are 0 and it is excluded from all counts. Formulas Q (Btu) = 400 x 24 x HDD gas furnace ($) = Q / (AFUE x 1,036,000) x gas price + Q/1e6 x 9 x elec price resistance ($) = Q / 3,412 x elec price heat pump ($) = Q / 3,412 / seasonal COP x elec price (elec price in $/kWh) Heat pump COP at temperature T (deg F), straight-line: standard: 2.3 + (T-17)/30, capped 3.6, floor 1.0; backup resistance share = (25-T)/30 clipped 0-1 cold-climate: 2.0 at 5, 2.6 at 17, 3.5 at 47 (slope continues), capped 3.8, floor 1.5; 1.0 below -13 Seasonal COP: for each month, COP at the normal daily low and high, weighted by (65 - T); months weighted by HDD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- state-energy-prices.csv (51 rows: 50 states and DC) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- elec_cents_kwh_winter_YYYY_YY EIA-861M residential revenue / sales, Oct-Mar (cents/kWh). elec_cents_kwh_12m_to_aug_2026 Same, Sep 2025-Aug 2026. gas_usd_mcf_winter_YYYY_YY EIA residential natural gas price, weighted by residential volume, Oct-Mar ($/Mcf). gas_usd_mcf_12m_to_aug_2026 Same, Sep 2025-Aug 2026 (blank where EIA withholds months). gas_months_reported_winter_2025_26 Months of the six that EIA reported (missing months are skipped). ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- state-electric-heat-equipment-recs2020.csv (51 rows) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From EIA RECS 2020 public household file v7, weighted with NWEIGHT. All values are % of ALL homes in the state. sample_homes Survey households in the state. pct_main_heat_electric Main heating fuel is electricity. pct_central_furnace_electric, pct_central_heat_pump, pct_ductless_heat_pump, pct_built-in_electric_units, pct_portable_electric_heaters, pct_boiler_electric, pct_other_electric Main electric heating equipment. pct_electric_resistance_main_heat Electric furnace + built-in units + portable heaters + electric boiler. Sources EIA Form 861M sales and revenue: https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/eia861m/ EIA natural gas residential prices and consumption: https://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/ng_pri_sum_a_EPG0_PRS_DMcf_m.htm NOAA U.S. Climate Normals 1991-2020: https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/products/land-based-station/us-climate-normals EIA RECS 2020: https://www.eia.gov/consumption/residential/data/2020/