Furnace replacement cost by size
The biggest driver is size: 40,000 BTU costs $4,550-$7,390 in Erie, while 120,000 BTU costs $5,420-$9,140, about 22% more. Ask every contractor to quote the same measured size.
| Size | Cost |
|---|---|
| 40,000 BTU | $4,550-$7,390 |
| 60,000 BTU | $4,770-$7,830 |
| 80,000 BTUMost common | $4,980-$8,270 |
| 100,000 BTU | $5,200-$8,710 |
| 120,000 BTU | $5,420-$9,140 |
Installed: Gas furnace, 95-96% AFUE
Furnace replacement cost by material or type
The gap between options is wide: gas boiler, hot water (high efficiency) costs about 1.4 times as much as gas furnace, 95-96% AFUE in Erie, and electric furnace trims about 32%.
| Type | Typical job |
|---|---|
| Electric furnace | $3,280-$5,720 |
| Gas furnace, 80% AFUE (single stage) | $4,280-$6,740 |
| Gas furnace, 95-96% AFUEMost common | $4,980-$8,270 |
| Propane furnace (95%) | $5,390-$8,790 |
| Oil furnace | $6,400-$10,220 |
| Gas furnace, 96%+ 2-stage or modulating | $6,720-$10,200 |
| Gas boiler, hot water (high efficiency) | $7,240-$11,440 |
Materials include waste and contractor markup. 80,000 BTU furnace
What will your Erie furnace cost?
We have already loaded Erie prices for this furnace replacement estimate. Enter your project details and ZIP code for a free planning estimate.
Add-ons and extra work
Check which of these 5 items your quote includes. The costliest line in Erie is "Ductwork repairs" at $2,410-$3,410 for the job.
- New PVC venting (when going 80% to 95%)$399-$1,050 / job
- Gas line work$307-$901 / job
- Ductwork repairs$2,410-$3,410 / job
- Variable-speed blower upgrade$460-$1,110 / job
- Smart thermostat$265-$495 / each
Show material-only prices
| Add-on | Materials |
|---|---|
| New PVC venting (when going 80% to 95%) | $173-$460 / job |
| Gas line work | $115-$402 / job |
| Ductwork repairs | $230-$575 / job |
| Variable-speed blower upgrade | $460-$1,040 / job |
| Smart thermostat | $132-$322 / each |
Installed price per unit
What makes Erie different for this job
Erie homes and the local housing stock
A furnace against the value of an Erie home
For furnace swaps, Erie housing is middle-aged by the standards of the other Pennsylvania cities NumeralQ covers: half the homes were built by 1949, against 1949 there.
The midpoint price of a furnace replacement works out to about 5.8% of what the median Erie home is worth ($115,200), the 4th highest of the 147 markets NumeralQ covers. Only 3 come out higher.
In Erie, where 54% of homes are owner-occupied and 64% of units are houses, the choice on a furnace replacement is usually the owner's. Ask for a room-by-room load calculation (ACCA Manual J), which the residential code requires for sizing.
Local planning note for Erie
Erie, Pittsburgh and Allentown side by side
Of the three, Erie is where a furnace replacement takes the biggest bite of a home's value: 5.8% of the median home, against 3.3% in Pittsburgh and 3.3% in Allentown. That's mostly lower home values, not higher prices.
For a furnace replacement in Erie or next door, pay for HVAC technicians is where the three split most: Allentown is 4% above the U.S. median and Erie is 3% below the U.S. median, per BLS. A contractor based in the lower-pay area may quote less for the same work.
| City | Typical job (midpoint) | Share of median home value | Pay for HVAC technicians vs U.S. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Erie | $6,625 | 5.8% | -3% |
| Pittsburgh | $6,770 | 3.3% | +2% |
| Allentown | $6,810 | 3.3% | +4% |
Typical job: midpoint of NumeralQ's typical-job range for each city. Pay: BLS May 2025 median for the trade vs the U.S. median.
Heating need in Erie
NOAA's normals give Erie 5,905 heating degree days a year (compared with medians of 5,900 across Pennsylvania weather stations and 5,483 across U.S. stations), a measure of how far below 65°F the days run.
About 84% of homes in Erie heat with piped gas, according to the Census Bureau (Pennsylvania: 51%; U.S.: 46%).
Pennsylvania's average residential gas price was $15.04 per Mcf in 2025 (EIA), against $15.34 nationally. Local utility rates vary.
The federal floor for a new gas furnace is 80% AFUE. A 90%-plus condensing furnace needs plastic venting and a drain, so ask whether the quote includes that work.
| Heating degree days | 5,905 |
|---|---|
| Nights at or below 32°F | 111 |
| Gas price, Pennsylvania 2025 | $15.04 per Mcf (U.S. $15.34) |
| Federal furnace minimum | 80% AFUE (non-weatherized gas) |
| HVAC license (Pennsylvania) | Local only (e.g., Philadelphia) |
| Where to check a license | Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General |
Local data checked October 2026 · Sources at the bottom of the page
When to plan this work in Erie
When to schedule a furnace replacement in Erie
In Erie, heating and cooling run least in June and September, the two mildest months at the Erie International Airport weather station by NOAA degree days. That's the easiest time to be without the system on the day of the work, and the time to plan a furnace replacement, rather than after a breakdown in January.
January is the heaviest heating month in Erie, with about 1,139 heating degree days at the Erie International Airport weather station, so an old furnace is most likely to fail then.
How Erie compares with nearby cities
Labor rates
For furnace replacement in Erie, contractors bill about $57-$74 per worker-hour for HVAC technicians, whose median pay is $28.36 an hour, 3% below the U.S. median. The difference covers insurance, taxes, overhead and profit.
HVAC technicians
Median pay: BLS May 2025. Billed rate: what a contractor charges per worker-hour, estimated at 2.0 to 2.6 times pay (insurance, payroll taxes, overhead, profit).
Before you sign in Erie
Get every quote to include
- fuel type, equipment model, capacity, and documented sizing basis
- venting, combustion air, gas or electrical connections, and ductwork
- removal, startup, commissioning, and safety checks included
- who checks and documents any required permits or inspections
Contractors per home in Erie
HVAC shops per home in Erie County
For replacing a furnace in Erie, the local pool is 65 plumbing, heating and air conditioning contractors in Erie County (Census, 2023): 5.4 per 10,000 homes, 30% below the U.S. rate of 7.7. That count includes plumbers, since the Census groups them with HVAC firms.
With a thin local pool, the best HVAC shops in Erie tend to book up first. Ask about lead time when you get furnace replacement quotes, and don't rule out contractors from the next county over.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does Furnace Replacement cost in Erie, PA?
Furnace replacement cost in Erie, PA: $4,980-$8,270 (80,000 BTU furnace). Each option in the price table above has its own range.
How does pay for HVAC technicians in the Erie area compare with the national median?
Median pay for HVAC technicians in the Erie, PA metro area is 3% below the national median, according to BLS data for May 2025. Pay is one input to a quote, not the price itself.
What climate zone is Erie in?
Erie County is in climate zone 5A on the DOE's county list, which energy codes use to set insulation and window levels.
Are federal home energy rebates available in Pennsylvania?
Pennsylvania's federal home electrification rebate program hasn't launched yet, according to NASEO's September 2026 status list.
Ready for your own number?
We have already loaded Erie prices for this furnace replacement estimate. Enter your project details and ZIP code for a free planning estimate.
Sources and methodology
- NumeralQ estimator (pricing as of 2026-10-26)
- Fixr cost guide, retrieved 2026-10-26
- Home Depot online prices, store 121, retrieved 2026-10-26
- NumeralQ estimate (no single published range; set from material prices and typical install hours)
- This Old House cost guide, retrieved 2026-10-26
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025 (https://www.bls.gov/oes/)
- City permit fee schedules, retrieved October 2026 (see the permit line for this page's source)
- NumeralQ pricing model v2: materials plus local labor, methodology at /methodology
- U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates, place-level tables B25018 (median rooms), B25035 (median year built), B25077 (median home value), B25024 (units in structure), B25003 (owner and renter occupancy) and B25041 (bedrooms) (https://data.census.gov/)
- NumeralQ pricing model v2: typical-job midpoints for all 147 markets, compared with the Census median home value (methodology at /methodology)
- International Code Council, 2021 International Residential Code, Chapter 14: M1401.3 (equipment sized by ACCA Manual S from Manual J loads) (https://codes.iccsafe.org/content/IRC2021P2/chapter-14-heating-and-cooling-equipment-and-appliances)
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025, metro-area median pay by trade compared with the U.S. median (https://www.bls.gov/oes/tables.htm)
- U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2023, establishments by county for NAICS 238160, 238170, 238220, 238310, 238320, 238330, 236118 and 561730, per 10,000 housing units from ACS 2020–2024 5-year table B25001 (https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/cbp.html)
- NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information, U.S. Climate Normals 1991–2020, monthly normals for the nearest station: average high and low, days with 0.10 in. of precipitation or more, heating and cooling degree days (https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/data/normals-monthly/1991-2020/access/)
- View local evidence & sources →
- NOAA climate normals source
- EIA natural gas prices source
- DOE furnace rules source
- Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General source
- DOE climate zone guide source
- NASEO source
We start from a national baseline and adjust it for Erie (1.10×). How we estimate